9 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
Meg on 1.12.2011




Yum! This was a hit at my house. All four kids ate it. My hubby drank a Guinness with it and was in heaven!
hjcary on 1.14.2011




Well Like the review above “All four kids ate it” with no problem. I doubled the recipe so I could put one in the freezer and I used Colby-Jack cheese instead of Parmesan.
txcookiemomster on 4.21.2011




I made this for my Dad, he loves Shepherd’s Pie, and now we all love Shepherd’s Pie! I used medium cheddar cheese, that’s the only change I made. I’ll make this many, many more times. Thanks for sharing. It is now a craving, dang it!
adobesol on 5.2.2011




Delicious, easy to prepare, hearty and nice presentation!!! I will make this one again and highly recommend.
lbt1018 on 8.17.2011




We had this last night and it was a hit! To be honest, when I was making it, I was wondering how good the end result would be. Very pleased with the taste. Even my 1 year old had seconds!!!
Jessica Kantola on 1.5.2012




This is a tight little recipe. My whole family enjoyed it – fairly predictable since hubby loves Shepherd’s Pie. I did use ground Angus beef and – after reading all the comments on this recipe – posted on Facebook that I was making “Cottage Pie” for dinner. That got a lot of questions and, in my seeking to explain, I found that Cowherders Pie made a bit more sense than “Cottage,” albeit a less appetizing mental image.
rkatzer on 3.5.2012




oh. my. goodness. This is the best recipe for shepherd’s pie I’ve ever tasted. I’ve made it about 3 or 4 times already this winter, and it is now in our winter dinner rotation! Thanks for sharing!!
You must be logged in to post a review.






12 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
camescook on 1.10.2011
Sounds like a quick way to get to a cottage pie. (Personal picky note: made with beef it is a cottage pie. Made with lamb, it is shepherd’s pie. Shepherds don’t herd cows.)
Trixine on 1.10.2011
I was going to make the same comment (shepherd’s pie vs. cottage pie)! If made with ground turkey what should it be called??? Regardless, this recipe is definitely going in my recipe box to try this weekend. Thanks!
sharoneason on 1.10.2011
Looks wonderful! I’ll just make it and let others pick away at what the proper name should be. smile
The Culinary Chronicles on 1.11.2011
Thanks for the clarification everyone!! If with Beef = Cottage Pie, Lamb = Shepherd’s Pie, then maybe Turkey = Thanksgiving Pie!
LOL@
jennreno on 1.11.2011
I always used a pound of ground sausage, and topped it off with instant garlic mashed potatoes. YUMM!
stephanie1963 on 1.12.2011
I’d not worry about the name. Our family has made this for years and called it Shepard’s Pie all along.
Sally Darling on 1.12.2011
Whatevery you call it, this is a MUST on my list. Right up my alley!
Kristi on 1.12.2011
I remember my grandmother making this once, years ago. She used white rice on the bottom first! I’ve been wanting to make it lately. Thanks for the recipe!
vlmarston on 1.12.2011
Who cares what it’s called? Sounds yummy and comforting during this cold weather! Will try this weekend!
cookbookqueen on 2.26.2011
I agree. Who cares what it is called? In the US, the terms “cottage pie” and “shepherd’s pie” are used interchangeably – both by famous chefs and by the general public. If ground beef “shepherd’s pie” is good enough for Martha Stewart, it’s good enough for me! (BTW, cottages don’t herd cows either.)
Thanks for sharing your recipe. It looks great!
You must be logged in to post a comment.