25 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
phadthai on 5.19.2010




I just made this batch again for my friends last weekend. It’s a really EASY, really GOOD recipe. Highly recommended!
If you’re worried about the cream in here, I made an adjustment that helps the cream go further:
Instead of a 28 oz can of diced tomatoes, use a 15 oz can diced and a 15 oz can crushed. Now that you’ve got at tomato-y sauce going on, you can splash in 1/4-1/2 of the amount of cream the recipe calls for.
kitchenlovenest on 6.1.2010




Please trust me–you must make this today!! I have been cooking Indian food for over 6 years, and this recipe beats out a ton of recipes from more “authentic” cookbooks. Based on the simplicity of the ingredients I was expecting an OK dish, but it was SPECTACULAR! Thank you Pastor Ryan!
Patti on 6.12.2010




I knew Chicken Tikka Masala from Robin Cook’s speech, but I’d never had it until now. Then today, I decided to make it on a whim, and when my roomie and I took our first bites, we just looked at each other and sighed in bliss. Spectacular is about the right adjective! This recipe will definitely get a lot of use around here!
carolinakate02 on 6.13.2010




I went out on a limb making this because my husband had never had Indian food before so he was very nervous but I’m so glad I did! It is one of my new favorite meals. Very easy to make and was unbelievably delicious. I would say that this recipe makes more than 6 servings.
candiacrew on 6.28.2010




I’ve always loved Chicken Tikka Masala and this is definitely a great recipe for it. If you like spicey you will definitely be wanting to add lots more hot. But the chicken is fantastic.
I did have to broil the chicken a little longer than described in the recipe and I allowed the sauce to simmer a bit longer to thicken. But a fantastic recipe for this classic dish.
funkycat on 7.22.2010




This recipe was NOT Easy! I haven’t been cooking for very long, and this is probably one of the most ambitious recipes I’ve tried. Since you have 3 things going on – broiler, rice, and stovetop, I really wouldn’t call it easy.
I had an issue trying to cut this recipe down to 4…which should’ve been easy on this site with its awesome conversion doodad, but it wasn’t. The water for the rice isn’t listed on the ingredients so I had to do the math for that, along with the Garam Masala spice and some other items.
Also, since I have a pretty nasty intolerance to garlic (it makes me nauseous), I had to skip that step, and I think it really screwed things up. Basically what happened was that my pan was too dry when I put in the spice mix and it kicked back at me, sending me into a coughing fit and smoking up my tiny apartment. I immediately grabbed the tomatoes and threw them in (thank God I’d already opened the can, time was of the essence here!). Next time I make it, I’ll do tomatoes first, then spice and let it simmer. You can definitely tell I’m an amateur here!
My finished product didn’t come out in that nice orange color from the picture – it was more like a sludgy brown. It might’ve had to do with how dark my Garam Masala was to begin with? (It’s sort of a deep red/brown.)
Overall, it tasted decent, but a bit too spicy for my friend and I, so we chopped up a fresh tomato and threw it in and that helped a lot.
I did find some fabulous naan at the Indian grocery, and we ate this with our fingers like real Indians!
I will be making this again, but with a few tweaks. Hopefully next time I’ll get it right. It is one of the most straight-forward recipes to make this, so thanks Pastor Ryan!
llenadadelgozo on 7.25.2010




Dude. I love this recipe so much. I’ve made it, and my husband made it tonight. Both times it turned out amazingly. I think it is perfect without adding any extra spice; he says next time he’ll add a little bit of kick. I definitely want to add this to my regular rotation.
anjaconda on 8.28.2010




We loved it! This was my first try at Indian Food and I can’t believe how good it turned out the first time thanks to your great recipe instructions. Thank you for sharing this – we’ll definitely make it again. We changed cream for half-and-half and it tasted great. We added whole wheat naan — yummy.
julied31 on 9.2.2010




I could eat this every day, and it’s just as good leftover. The only changes I’ve made to this is using white or brown rice and not adding any heat or cilantro to it. Personally, I think the garam masala is spicy enough (I made my own). For the kids, I just take one of the chicken breasts after it’s been broiled and serve that with the rice and peas. They can handle the cumin & coriander, but not the sauce.
Excellent recipe!!!
uthiker on 9.7.2010




I agree with all others! This is fantastic! I have never made Indian food before but I will make this over and over again. It smells fantastic when its cooking and tastes even better. Don’t be intimidated by the list of ingredients…..make it today!
You must be logged in to post a review.






9 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
surggreys07 on 11.26.2009
I honestly….have no words for how just wonderful this was! I doubled it because I had to feed around 12 people but it was gone!!! And they were already asking when I would make it again!
alexismommy on 3.16.2010
I’ve made this recipe twice now and we love, love, love it! I omitted the jalapenos the 2nd time I made it as my 6 yr. old couldn’t eat it with them. She loves it with out them. Great recipe!
nursechacha on 3.23.2010
I just made this tonight for dinner and it was a hit! I didn’t use any heat in the batch I made. This was much easier than I thought that it would be esp. with the help of my hubby with the chopping duties. This would be a great idea for a dinner party if doubled. I would and will make it again.
phadthai on 4.27.2010
I’ve made this recipe 4-5 times for parties since it was posted on PW’s cooking blog. It’s easy, delicious and toooootally bad for you. WHAT ELSE DO YOU NEED TO KNOW?
I only make two changes:
1. I make to it is that I use 2 15 oz cans of tomatoes… one diced and one crushed. This produces a nice creamy tomato sauce.
2. Because I have a lil’ thicker tomato sauce thing going on by subbing crushed, the cream goes a lot further. I use maybe 1/4 to 1/2 the amount.
Is it proper this way? Nah. Delicious? Heck yes.
karenklasi on 4.28.2010
I have never, ever had Tikka Masala this good. Anywhere. EVER. I made it last week and already the kids are asking when I’ll make it again. I actually hid the leftovers in the waaaay back of the fridge so that I didn’t have to share them.
Rock on, Pastor Ryan!
emilyborland on 5.1.2010
Wholey Moley this is SO GOOD. I am always looking for good Indian food recipes, and this one definately tasted how I WANTED it to. This was very very well falvored and I will make it again and again and again. Can you please give us a Chicken Vindaloo version?!?
mrslindsaymiller on 5.24.2010
Making this recipe tomorrow night for dinner!
Can t wait to find out how great it is!
mandicrocker on 7.20.2010
This is AMAAAAAAAAAAAAZING. Seriously. Just delicious. Go Pastor Ryan. Fo reals!!! I made it a long time ago for my boyfriend & I… making it again tonight for ME! I’m doing a dance!!!
ionlyweardresses on 2.3.2011
I made this vegetarian with tofu and it’s one of my favorite recipes!
You must be logged in to post a comment.