24 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
lexie on 5.19.2010




I love this pizza crust. It is my go-to recipe whenever I am making homemade pizza. It is so simple to make and tastes great after the dough rests in the fridge for a few days. The start of every great pizza starts with PW’s pizza crust!
Stacy on 5.19.2010




I was a bit dubious since my previous pizza dough recipe calls for 5x this much yeast, but my family likes a thinner crust so I figured it was worth a shot. I made it ahead and baked it up about 24 hours later. Made a double bacth for 4 pizzas.
To me it was “ok” (I am the lone family member who prefers a thicker, breadier crust) but everyone else (all 7 of them) said it was the best crust I’ve ever made, so I think I’m over-ruled! Mine WAS very wet and sticky so it took a lot of olive oil on my hands to even get it to resemble a BALL, and I think that all that oil helped the flavor/texture, also. It browned up nicely a round the edge of the crust and most of the kids even ate the crust! I added a bit of oregano and garlic powder to the dough but I always do that, so it was the recipe itself that won my family over. Easy peasy, so as long as I remember ahead of time (I’m shooting for a few DAYS next time), I should be good to go. And save $$$ on yeast!
WestsWife on 5.20.2010




I love this pizza crust; I use it for everything from pizza to stromboli. It is wonderful! It’s so simple to make too! The first time I made it my first thought when taking it out of the mixer was “uh-oh, this is too sticky… what did I do wrong?” But once I put it in the bowl and coated it with olive oil it became much easier to handle.
For me, the best way to handle the mixed dough is to make sure the bowl I transfer it to is completely coated in olive oil. I use one hand to take the dough out of my stand mixer, drop it in the bowl and sort of swish it around. Then I flip it over and do that again, cover it with a wet cloth and let it rise. It makes two LARGE pizzas or about six strombolies. It rises in the oven, so the stromboli ends up being really “puffy” but it is delicious! I LOVE this dough!
mollyp on 5.27.2010




Let the dough come to room temperature before trying to stretch it. I used 2 cups regular flour and 2 cups whole wheat and it tasted great, but because I used it straight from the refrigerator (guests arrived early!!), I was only able to stretch it out for ONE thick crust pizza. Really tasted good though and is super easy!
kitchenlovenest on 6.1.2010




Very good. I’m still searching for the perfect pizza dough recipe, but if I never find it, this will be one I return to again and again.
ashdmc on 6.4.2010




I absolutely love this pizza crust! This was the first time I had ever made homemade crust. I was a bit worried after mixing because the dough was so sticky. But, after getting it all into the oiled bowl it came together. Making the dough the night before is definitely a huge help!
shep on 6.28.2010




I made this last night and it worked great. We put one on the regular baking pan and one on a pizza stone. The pizza stone one was a little crispier, but both were delicious.
The Girly Girl Cooks on 7.11.2010




I love this recipe! It is so simple and easy to throw together! I had trouble using this crust for the calzones though….that is most likely 100% my fault.
bellanutella on 7.25.2010




I’ve made this dough successfully about as many times as I’ve failed miserably at it. The messiest, wettest failure was when I accidentally put the yeast water in BEFORE the olive oil. 2 hours later, I still had a wet flour ball; no rising goin’ on. It can be a little hard to stretch, too, but it bakes up nicely when you’re done fighting with it!
You must be logged in to post a review.






19 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
Mangiate on 3.15.2010
I made this pizza crust a couple of weeks ago and it turned out pretty good, but I changed the flour out for a whole wheat/all-purpose flour mixture. If you are going to do this use 2 cups all-purpose flour and 2 cups whole wheat. If you don’t do this your crust will turn out like cardboard.
audreyinez on 3.18.2010
Thanks Mangiate! I was just wondering about a whole wheat substitution.
ericame on 3.24.2010
It was a bit chewier than I expected, but tasted good. It was surprisingly easy and quick to put together.
blazingsmile on 3.30.2010
This was my first attempt at making pizza dough, and it was bad, bad, bad. I’m still having nightmares.
The recipe wasn’t informative enough. I had no idea I had to let the dough “knead” enough for it to come together in a soft, mound-y ball. From the pics on pioneerwoman.com website, it was rather wet/sticky, so that’s when I stopped the mixer. Once it rested (24 hours in the fridge for me), I couldn’t roll it out/stretch it to save my life. After taking all my aggressions out on the dough (to no avail), I ended up tossing it and trying a different one from Foodtv.com site. If you’re going to try this, mix the dough longer than you think, it should come together in a soft, smooth ball on the side of the mixer when it’s done. Shouldn’t be sticky at all. Also, I don’t know if you’re supposed to let it warm to room temp. before rolling it out, the directions don’t specify.
lilamz on 3.31.2010
This is a simple basic pizza crust. The directions are easy to follow. There is a difference between sticky and wet. You want the dough to be sticky but able to form a ball. If it feels too wet or you can’t shape it then you need to mix it a little longer.
sheralee on 4.1.2010
I absolutely loved this pizza dough! I threw it together last night before dinner put it in the fridge for 24 hours and we prepared it for dinner tonight. It was delicious. We sauteed crimini mushrooms for ours and just cheese for the girls. The girls said it was the best pizza we have ever made-which is high praise from teenaged daughters.
emilynbee on 4.5.2010
I made this dough last week for a pizza night with my boyfriend, and we absolutely loved it. I did it by hand (my stand mixer doesn’t come to college with me, at least not until I move into an apartment next year!), and based on other reviews I just kept kneading and mixing past “sticky mass” and well into “smooth ball” territory. It tasted great, worked wonderfully even though I only let it rest for a few hours, and I will definitely use this one again!
Woven & Spun on 4.10.2010
I’ve tried many crust recipes, but this was the best. I did it by hand because I don’t have a stand mixer and only mixed until it just pulled together.
I only let it rest for about 2 1/2 hrs and I can’t wait to do it again & rest it overnight.
Thanks PW : )
vinegarfizz on 4.14.2010
Hands down, this is the easiest and tastiest pizza crust recipe I have ever made! I threw half of the dough back in the fridge and pulled it out a few days later to make Italian cheesy bread…mama mia! Sooooo good!
karenklasi on 4.28.2010
I love this pizza crust! The first time I made it, I used half wheat flour and it was fine. When I made the recipe as-is, though, my family went nuts. Now I make it every Sunday and use it during the week for whichever happens to be Pizza Night. I just made it again so that the after-school crowd on Friday can make their own pizzas. Thanks, Ree!
You must be logged in to post a comment.