37 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
Karen R. on 2.14.2014
The Best Chicken Tortilla Soup I ever had! I follow the recipe exactly except I added a some bouillon cubes to give it more flavor.
JillyBean on 10.16.2013
Fantastic!! This is the new favorite soup in our home! The only change I made was only adding 2 cups of water . . . we like thicker soups . . . & I added a little cayenne pepper to kick up the heat a little. Thanks for another great recipe!!
Christine Brown on 6.11.2013
Was at a Mexican restaurant on Friday night – LOVED their chicken tortilla soup and have been craving it ever since. Found this recipe…WOWWWWWWW!! Even better than at the restaurant…heartier and deeper flavors.
I made a quadruple batch (everyone in my house loves soup and we like to have leftovers). Made exactly to recipe and multiplied everything by 4 with these exceptions…used only 2 cans of black beans instead of 4, and instead added 2 cups of minute rice and 2 cups of hot water during the last 15 minutes of cook time. (The little bit of rice was a really nice addition.) I also used 2 whole rotisserie chickens for ease & simplicity vs. rubbing/baking chicken breasts.
My fiancé asked to have this on his “Top 3 Rotation”! =] Thank you PioneerWoman!!
Allison on 4.8.2013
Seriously the best chicken tortilla soup I have made (and I have tried a few!) The cornmeal/masa is a great addition and really gives it an amazing flavor, don’t leave this part out!
10 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
on 3.20.2012
I chose this because I had a can of Rotel tomatoes with green chilies and this recipe had some of everything I liked about the others I checked. It was probably the most delicious tortilla soup I’ve had east of Taos. I used a rotisserie chicken to make the broth and used about half the chicken. Fabulous. Absolutely nothing to change here. Can’t wait for the leftovers.
laura holt-kabel on 12.28.2011
I made this soup yesterday and it was a big hit with the crowd. Luckily I kind of doubled it so there are leftovers for my husband and I. I added a can of cheese soup to it for something new and it was delicious. Thanks for sharing the recipe !!
okterri on 11.8.2011
Yummy! I only used about 2 cups of water, and since my husband is not a bean eater, I stirred in a can of refried beans instead of the black beans (if he noticed, he didn’t say :)_The soup was thicker, and we liked it that way.
Kim Anderson on 10.20.2011
I made this last night…my husband said, “I believe this is the best soup you’ve ever made.” I had left-overs because it’s just the two of us. I’m going to try freezing it for later use. Has anyone done this? This is definitely a KEEPER, thanks for the recipe!
Amy on 2.9.2011
I made this once for my husband and now he requests it all the time! Thanks Ree!