43 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
Angela Kieffer on 8.31.2013
I’ve used this recipe now a few times. Everyone loves it. It goes great with the corn pudding, a recipe I also got from the Pioneer Woman website.
Mel on 9.11.2012
I feel like I must be missing something here. Easy and quick to make but all I tasted was the overwhelming worcestershire flavor. It remains to be seen if the boyfriend will like it. Next time, I’ll replace most of the worcesterchire with beef stock and see if that’s more to my taste. Sorry Ree, this is the first recipe of yours that I don’t love.
christynbj on 5.16.2012
Wonderful, easy and everyone eats it. You can’t ask for much more than that!
Jen Shinsky on 5.5.2012
This recipe was very easy to make and tasted delicious. I followed the recipe exactly as written. Now that I know what it tasts like, I will add to it the next time. My husband would like to have cheese on his.
18 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Destiny on 8.17.2014
All four of us really like this sandwich. Browning the rolls makes a big difference in how good it is. My 17 year old son, who is a cheese freak and rarely eats a sandwich without cheese, first mentioned it would need cheese. After his second sandwich, he decided it was fine just the way it was.
Someone mentioned it was too strong with the Worcestershire sauce. I didn’t measure how much I put in and just added until it smelled good but not overpowering. I know this can be adjusted.
tinafruge on 1.25.2013
my husband’s all time favorite meal. and mine as well =)
heatherjey on 8.27.2010
I made this for my husband and it is now his favorite sandwich!! I must say, I loved it too!! Two thumbs up!
melanie875 on 6.1.2010
Tried this just last night and my husband LOVED it! Definitely think adding some melted cheese would be wonderful.
raerae58 on 5.29.2010
I have made this recipe twice now and it will be a keeper. I think it came out better the second time. I will try bell peppers with the onions next time. Oh and I did cut down on the butter. That much butter scares me. LOL