19 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
kitchenlovenest on 6.3.2010




I made this for Valentine’s Day this year, and they were SO GOOD. A little pricey to make, but oh-so worth it.
carnivoregirl on 9.30.2010




This was soooo yummy! Even my picky husband loved it! I will definitely make this again. Thanks Ree!
senoritabonita on 10.18.2010




This was super yummy! A little pricey, but definitely delicious. I think I may try the same ingredients next time, except use a cheaper cut of meat.
I cooked mine in the crock pot on high for 4 hours, and it was perfect.
I’m going to take the advice of another commentor, and use the leftover “juice” as a base for soup.
beefisbest on 11.23.2010




I’m so glad I saved this for a special meal. The ribs were fairly expensive, but totally worth it! My guests loved this meal! The meat was so tender and flavorful.
dliff on 12.1.2010




These are the best things ever. I made them with my mom while I was visiting her and she can’t stop talking about them – she forwarded the recipe to everyone she knows and has made it at least once more for friends. We used baby carrots instead of cutting up big carrots. The carrots were melt in your mouth like butter – SO GOOD. The meat is so tender and delicious. They are perfect over creamy goat cheese polenta. A big hit!!
lililoumom on 1.7.2011




I’ve made this twice, and everyone loved it! I switched out the goat cheese for asiago, and it was fabulous. I’m making it again for Sunday dinner with our best friends. How better to show the love?
mrsq on 1.28.2011




My husband said, “I think this is the best meal you have ever made for me.” (Awww.)
I used bacon, but I should have cut back on the salt; the bottom portion of the pan was a little salty. We served with creamy mashed potatoes and it was the ultimate winter comfort food
You must be logged in to post a review.






30 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
Nancy Cordaro on 11.16.2009
I have this in the oven and it smells amazing in my house right now! Was wondering if it might be one of those kitchen sink dishes that would work adding other things you may have on hand like parsnips or mushrooms, um, not that I have parsnips on hand or anything, just thought they’d be good!
Anyway, a friend just called me from the market telling me that after she heard what I was making (this) for dinner she went on your site, got the recipe, and is making them as well! It’s gone viral!! Look out! There may be a severe short ribs shortage (say that 3 times fast) in the country very soon!
Trish in MO on 11.18.2009
What if you don’t have a dutch oven? (I keep TRYing to win one…hehe) What type of pot can be used, or can I do this in a crock pot?
kasphoto on 11.19.2009
@ Nancy Cordaro…I made this the other night and added mushrooms. They were so good! The next day, I removed the fat from the leftovers and made gravy out of it. It was amazing! I’m pretty sure you could add many veggies to the mix and it would be spectacular!
surggreys07 on 11.26.2009
This was the first meal I cooked for my parents since I had moved out. They were very impressed! They loved it!! The rosemary and thyme just make the house smell wonderful!!
denvillekori on 12.5.2009
We made this on a snowy Saturday afternoon, and it turned out great! I wouldn’t change a thing. Although, it would probably be really good with mushrooms, or parsnips, or… you get the idea.
bumpo11 on 12.5.2009
My sister in law and I made this tonight and it was excellent! There is enough of the stew part left over to save and make a stew. It’s a keeper!
inquisitrix on 12.9.2009
This was the very first time I have ever made ribs before and it was DE-LISH! Just don’t do what I did and start your recipe to late in the afternoon – We didn’t eat until 9pm and the wonderful smells almost drove us over the cliff! I even made the creamy polenta and it was a perfect 10! Thank you, Ree!!!
therealannabell on 12.28.2009
I first made this for my husband a few weeks ago. I passed the recipe on to my mother, who then passed it on to all my sisters-in-law, grandmother, and friends!! Everyone loves the recipe!! I made it again this weekend and I just love the way it makes our house smell. It turns out perfect everytime. I like to make mashed potatoes with it, but my mom said the polenta is delicious!!
ps
My brother and sister-in-law bought me your cookbook for Christmas! I made the Chicken Pot Pie and loved it. Thanks for the great recipes. When are you going to come up to Oregon for a signing??
lucyfash on 12.28.2009
Wow! These turned out so nice and tender. Due to the travesty of my not having a Dutch oven (!), I had to rely on my crock pot. I turned up the heat to HIGH and suffered the rest of the afternoon from the temptation of the delicious smell they filled our apartment with! When it came time to serve my ever-patient husband, I kept it simple by putting them over mashed potatoes. There will surely be a replay of these!
happyhomemaker1957 on 12.29.2009
I made this for Christmas Eve dinner. OMGoodness, it was absolutely delicious. Will definitely make again and again.
You must be logged in to post a comment.