17 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
LaLaLinz on 5.17.2010
These are yummy! I made a double batch yesterday and have probably eating 15 of them – not counting all of the dough I ate as I was baking them! I took them to work today and they were a hit with my coworkers as well! Thanks for sharing.
carolinacollegecook on 7.5.2010
This is my go-to cookie recipe. I’ve used this recipe numerous times & each time they’re delicious. The dough is amazing and the cookies are no different. Definitely a winner!
laurasmom on 7.12.2010
These cookies are delicious! I took them to a party and brought home a clean plate, everyone loved them. Thanks for sharing such a wonderful recipe!
catie27 on 11.12.2010
Delicious! My husband managed to grab a hunk of the dough while I wasn’t looking and after that it was hard to keep him out of the bowl. They baked up beautifully – golden brown and soft.
Jamie on 11.30.2010
these are delicious!!! i would highly recommend doubling the recipe. they go fast. 
abbyv on 2.28.2011
What tasty cookies!! All of my favorites in one fluffy, chewy, chocolatey disk.
LOVE THEM!
And the recipe doubles beautifully for taking to work/school/etc.
Mrs. Farnsworth on 4.19.2011
Best cookies ever! I like super fluffy, fluffy cookies so I added a half tsp of baking powder to it (although I have made these just as written) and are delicious! We use dark chocolate chips too…I think I need some now. (especially the dough)
Jess on 5.5.2011
“Magnificent cookie” is an apt description. Maybe it’s the coloring from the peanut butter, but these cookies even look especially delicious. Definitely a keeper. Thanks!
skyblue on 8.4.2011
These are seriously amazing! Soft and chewy with a delicious flavor. My official taste tester, aka my husband, devoured my first batch of these. I made a double batch a few days ago for family visiting from out-of-town and they raved about them. Definitely a keeper, thanks!
hermann329 on 8.18.2011
AMAZING cookies!!! I made these last night to bring to work today, and I know I’ll be keeping this recipe for years to come! The cookies are not only delicious in flavor, but they’re soft too. I used chocolate chunks instead of chips. They turned out wonderfully.
You must be logged in to post a review.
9 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
Amber on 3.9.2010
These were Sooo… good! Yum!
Lauren's Latest on 3.9.2010
Delicious! My husband and I loved them! The batter was pretty fabulous too!
redkate on 3.10.2010
I’m making these tonight, but in honor of St Pats, I am using green M&Ms instead of chocolate chips!
layseab on 3.15.2010
Made these last night. So Easy! Delicious! and recipe worked great AS IS for High Altitude!
Katherine on 4.6.2010
These are delicious! The first batch disappeared in no time and I’m making them again today!
LaLaLinz on 5.16.2010
Delicious! I made a batch today. I might have given myself an upset stomach from eating so much of the dough! This recipe will definitely be making repeat appearances at my house!
cheshirecattat on 9.4.2010
These cookies are absolutely wonderful! They are my new go-to recipe when I need a cookie fix.
2boysmommy on 9.9.2010
Soooo yummy! I should have doubled the recipe because I made them last night and they are almost gone this morning! Yum!!
Jamie on 2.25.2011
SO GOOD! Definitely need to double the recipe.
You must be logged in to post a comment.