8 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
Jenna on 9.8.2014
I was so excited to try this recipe and I had a bunch of friends over last night for the football game, so I thought this would be great. I rarely modify a recipe the first time I make it, so that I fully experience what it is supposed to bebefore I make any alterations. However, when I went to put in the thyme I thought, god that seems like A LOT. I was correct. It overpowered the whole meal. Also, as someone else stated it needed some additional salt. I think the potential is there but definitely needs some altering. If I made it again I would use a small fraction of the thyme and add some more salt.
AZJ22 on 1.25.2014
This was great! I added chopped button mushrooms, because my family is crazy about mushrooms + beef.
Sadly I could not find Smithwick’s here… so after some Googling, I bought Guinness STOUT (not lager). The 1 pint 6oz (22oz) bottle I found in my Safeway store was perfect, although the original recipe here calls for two bottles of Smithwick’s and from what I could find on Google, they are 12oz each standard.
sdmomchef on 10.28.2013
Loved this recipe. Would suggest decreasing the amount of thyme and adding a sautéed onion. But overall my family thoroughly enjoyed this recipe.
mandykelly28 on 2.20.2013
wounderful flavor . i made it gluten free by useing bisquick gluten free instead of flour. yummy
fightpilotswife on 12.14.2012
Can’t believe I forgot to review this one the first time I made it!! It’s super simple and DELICIOUS! I do add frozen pearl onions at the same time as the peas, but that’s simply personal preference. Perfect with french bread and beer. Thanks!!
3 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Mylittlenutmeg on 9.25.2011
We don’t have Smithwick’s beer out here, can you suggest another brand?
aliciaburnstoast on 9.29.2010
My fiance would LOVE this. Totally adding it to my recipe box.
mermaidswheel on 2.25.2010
I made this with chicken last night (I don’t eat mammals) and it was really good. It did need some salt, though.