10 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
Nicole K on 9.2.2012
While these are very tasty, they aren’t a “true” whoopie pie…more like a cookie sandwich. Came out like a true cookie, where whoopie pies are more like a cake. Very good though!
bonnie on 2.10.2012
I gave this a 5 “glove” rating because I don’t know if I messed up or what. They’re good and very easy to make. My problem was mine are huge. So huge there was no way I was getting 18 pies from one batch. I had to go buy another cake mix and could only put 1 TBS of filling in them. I bought a 2-oz scoop just for this recipe. At first I thought I messed up and bought a bigger one, but it’s definetly a 2-oz.I would have loved more filling in them because they are pretty flat. But like I said, they are good. Any solutions?
atablackbelt1997 on 4.17.2011
These were FABULOUS! They look like I bought them from a bakery! I did find the filling to be the tiniest bit thin, but once they went in the refrigerator and came back out the next day, they were perfect! I took them to a potluck and had so many requests for the recipe, I cannot believe they were so easy to make!
nurse2bake on 2.25.2011
MMMMM Good.
These were awesome. I have made these for Christmas and Valentines Day. One suggetion that I have is to make the filling ahead of time and place in the fridge while the pies are baking, this way the filling does not ooze out of the pies. These are awesome. I also tried with devil’s food cake mix and they are equally just as yummy.
ameeanda on 2.20.2011
These were really delicious, but the filling was definitely runny and didn’t stay put! 
But they still got eaten and enjoyed! Any tips on how to make the filling less runny?
8 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
nurse2bake on 2.25.2011
These were awesome. I have made these for Valentine’s Day and Christmas. Every loves them and think I spent hours baking. One suggestion I have is making the filling ahead of time and placing it in the fridge while the pies are baking. I found this keeps the filling from oozing out of the pies.
cjansmile on 1.31.2011
Every year I make my honey red velvet cake for Valentine’s Day….this year, this will be a new twist to his favorite
Thanks for posting this!
ClaireS on 9.5.2010
Gonna make these tomorrow as a Labor Day cookout treat (Devil’s Food version w/homemade mocha icing)! Thanks for posting so I could run across it ….. and love the fact I have everything in the pantry to make them!
mjoverfelt on 5.20.2010
I also made spice cake whoopie pies and they were good also!
Queen Weasley on 4.25.2010
I made a batch and took them to the clinic where I work, now they all think I’m an amazing baker. I couldn’t believe how easy these were to make. I bought a cookie scoop, which really helped me keep the cookies uniform in size. Thanks for making me look good!