5 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
mistyinhotnhumidhouston on 12.10.2010




I should have rated this soup along time ago, because it was about the first on TK, now there are many just like it. I have made this soup so many times I no longer need the recipe because it is in my head. It is my all time favorite, hearty, warm, comfort soup. It is the perfect starting point for different combinations. My daughter has added chicken (instead of hamburger) and broccoli to the original recipe. It is also similar to Ree’s Cauliflower soup. The base is the same. I sometimes leave out the sourcream because it really is so good with or without it. It is perfect and so Yummy!!! If you have not made it, what are you waiting for?!!!!
larealme on 11.8.2011




I just tried this recipe for the first time tonight after getting the link from a comment on PW, and boy, am I glad I did! This is absolutely delicious and the perfect comfort food for a chilly fall night. Everybody in my family just loved it and will definitely be adding this to my recipe box.
ckincheloe on 10.3.2012




This was so tasty! I will be adding it to our regular round of winter soups. Thank you for sharing!
Sleepymommy on 12.30.2012




Made for a friend who just had a baby….made with ground chicken and chicken stock. Turned out great!
bethcrd on 1.13.2013




I made this last night and my whole family devoured it! No leftovers! I didn’t have beef broth so I used chicken broth. Also was lacking celery in the pantry, I just omitted it. Otherwise, I followed the recipe as stated. Delicious!
You must be logged in to post a review.






7 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
connieq on 7.15.2009
this looks like a recipe I need to try…and I think I already have all the ingredients, except the sour cream…and perhaps I could subsitute plain yogurt for that!
Amanda on 7.20.2009
This was really good!
After I got the soup in the bowls, I sprinkled with a little Lawry’s Seasoned Salt and it was *amazing*!
shinyhappymommy on 7.24.2009
This was my first Tasty Kitchen recipe to try. I loved it. I didn’t have carrots, so I used some reconstituted dried carrots. I can’t wait to try it again with fresh ones, it will taste even better. It’s very hearty and tastes like comfort food.
copperkettleconfections on 8.7.2009
I really like this recipe but of course made a couple of changes…I don’t normally endorse processed cheese but in this recipe it definately gives that extra creamy texture. I also like a dash of nutmeg! Thanks for a great recipe!
maglo on 9.26.2009
This is one of my families favorite soup. When my kids were growing up it was the only soup they would eat. I felt at least they were getting some vegetables with the carrots and potatoes in there.
amyinbmore on 11.17.2009
So delicious! I only made a couple changes… used ground turkey instead of beef, omitted the carrots and sour cream, and added chopped tomatoes at the very end of the cooking process. It actually tasted like a cheeseburger!
eastcolomom on 4.16.2010
Great recipe, great soup! My 3 year old devoured it! Thanks for the recipe!
You must be logged in to post a comment.