49 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
looneybaker on 7.4.2012
Great easy to make cookies! They were a big hit with my family.
Like others, I did have some PB filling left over when doubling this recipe.
nannymimi on 12.31.2011
Very Very Good!!!! Made these for a family gathering and they were gone in a flash.
Heather G. on 12.26.2011
These were sooo good!! I really noticed a difference (not a good one) when I used a cheaper cake mix. I’ll stick with Duncan Hines or Betty Crocker for sure. Definitely a keeper!
sarajtn on 7.18.2011
Absolutely delicious. I made them for a friend who loves peanut butter, and these were a huge hit. Once assembled, the cookies are huge, so one is plenty for a serving. Definitely make sure you don’t overbake, as having the cookie chewy is key with the filling.
Liliputtin on 7.2.2011
Oh. Wow. These are so yummy and rich. I can’t have more than 1.5 in a single sitting and even then they need milk! I would also say there is more than enough filling with this recipe, so try halving the amounts. They remind me a bit of a “whoopie pie” a friend brought to school once. So good and deceptively easy!
30 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
The Three Little Piglets on 4.20.2011
Oh my those look good! I love anything with peanut butter and confectoners’ sugar together…
peanutbutterlover on 4.12.2011
Ive made these several times and they are absolutely amazing!! I love to keep them chilled they taste and last longer that way
HealthyOne on 3.9.2011
These are soo good. One of my favorites now. Thanks for sharing!
kathee on 3.5.2011
brilliant!! I’m making these tomorrow!!
vasichde on 2.26.2011
I can’t decide. I will either never make these cookies again, or I will make these cookies every single week! They are so tasty, so easy, and so bad for my waistline! Evil to have in the house, but a sin to never make them again! Thanks for a great recipe.