6 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
Katie on 9.3.2013
Easy and delicious! I made it exactly as described for a family gathering, and it got rave reviews. As others have said, all the marshmallows that were mixed in with the filling rose up to the top while cooking. They got a bit too “toasty” looking (I just covered them with some more marshmallows that I only lightly browned, and then added graham crackers and chocolate sauce to cover the rest of the overly-toasty ones). This all turned out to be a matter of aesthetics, and didn’t effect the taste at all. I will definitely be making this again!
Phoebe on 5.29.2013
I messed up and it came out a bit wonky because of it. Whoops. It still tasted insanely good! Thanks for the recipe! Next time, I’ll pay more attention and I’m sure it’ll be incredible the way it was meant to be
lifeasamama on 2.12.2012
this was absolutely delicious…. the only change i’m going to make next time is to leave out the layer of marshmallows / hot fudge sauce at the bottom of the cake. all it did was make the bottom crust candy-like, and i LOVE the crust the way it’s supposed to be. but other than that, this was a complete winner. i’ll be making this again, that’s for sure!
emskyrooney on 7.28.2011
Made this for my husband for his birthday! It was DELICIOUS! The only change I made was that I didn’t add any marshmallows to the top at the end- for some reason all of the marshmallows I mixed in rose to the top of the cake and were nicely toasted by the end of the baking so I didn’t think it needed more. So tasty though and am regretting that I only got to eat one piece before hubby scarfed the rest down!
tmccabe8 on 4.4.2011
I made this for church. Everyone loved it. Mine weren’t as pretty as yours but they were delicious!
5 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
scarlettcook on 3.28.2011
Glad you enjoyed it, lydiajo!! We think it’s pretty fantastic!
lydiajo on 3.28.2011
Very easy, very yum. My sister in law told me that it looked like it came out of a magazine. thanks!
CookBakeandDecorate on 3.24.2011
Oh My Heavens!!! I think my heart just skipped a beat! Love smores and love cheesecake. Put the 2 together, genius. Cant wait to try this.
Ambition's Kitchen on 3.24.2011
This looks killer! I love anything smores!
Megan {Country Cleaver} on 3.23.2011
I love it. I love it. I love it! Gosh this can’t possibly look any better Can’t wait to whip this one up Ms. V! ~Megan