21 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
Ree on 5.17.2010




I absolutely loved this recipe. Loved it. The small amount of tomato juice gives the soup the most delicate tangy undertone, and the Parmesan injects a whole lot of flavor. I think using cream as the recipe states would be extra delicious, but honestly, it was perfectly good with half-and-half. Also note that depending on the appetites of those eating, this recipe makes 2 to 4 servings. If you’re cooking for four really hungry people, you might want to double the recipe. Leftovers are never a bad thing!
karien on 5.18.2010




My husband really loved this recipe. I liked it but next time I’ll definitely replace the white button mushrooms with something a bit more interesting – then it should be perfect
goodwync on 5.18.2010




This is a wonderful recipe!!! Since I first found it, I’ve made it about 25 times. I’ve shared it with family and friends and everyone loves it as much as I do. It is amazing in taste and ease of preparation. Please don’t let the lengthy ingredient list stop you from making it. They’re simple ingredients that add up to SO MUCH WONDERFUL FLAVOR!!! My husband isn’t a mushroom fan and he loves this soup. The only recommendation / change I would make is to at least DOUBLE the recipe every time you make it!!
meeshiesmom on 5.25.2010




Love this recipe! So tasty and simple. I did double it when I made it. Thanks!
kitchenlovenest on 6.1.2010




Fantastic! This has become my absolute favorite soup. I’ve made it 3 times, twice for nice dinner parties–both times people have loved it. It’s easy to make the night before, and the flavor is rich and wonderful.
egpoindexter on 7.27.2010




Made it with half in half instead of heavy cream, and it was delicious! All we needed for dinner was a cup of this, a light green salad and some crusty bread for dipping…yummy! Thank you for sharing such a wonderful and easy recipe!
mellispretty on 7.27.2010




This soup is very tasty. I subbed half the mushrooms with cirmini and the wine for chicken broth. It took a lot of salt and pepper, much more than a pinch. I will make it again. Thanks!
shellbell on 8.2.2010




This soup has amazing flavors, and it’s extremely easy to throw together. Which makes it dangerous because this is not something I should be eating frequently. (As Cookie Monster says, “It’s a sometimes food.”) I was hoping for a soup similar to one I grew up eating in my family’s favorite restaurant, so I omitted the tomato juice. I’ll add it next time because I think the only thing it was lacking was acid. I also omitted the celery and subbed vermouth for the Chablis.
pukingpastilles on 8.4.2010




Rich, creamy, and flavorful! I adore this soup; it could very well be in a fancy restaurant. Heavenly! I did decrease the amount of parmesan because the first time I made it, there was too much. But I really think that is personal preference.
Excellent recipe! A keeper!
dhgal on 8.5.2010




Fantastic recipe! Easy to make with wonderful results! I can’t wait to make it again!
You must be logged in to post a review.






39 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
hughes on 1.20.2010
I made this last night! So easy and so good! My husband loves it too!!!! MMMMMM!!!!
vickit on 1.22.2010
This recipe looks extremely good. Will be making this one very soon. Thank you.
angelfood on 2.2.2010
This looks delicious. I’ll be trying it this weekend.
maryloves2cook on 2.2.2010
Congrats on Ree recommending the recipe! I am excited to try this and to find out it is only four servings (my husband doesn’t like mushrooms)!
Mama Holli of Nobody Puts Mama In A Corner! on 2.2.2010
This looks divine!!!!! We are a mushroom family over here! Will have to try!
Katie on 2.2.2010
Made this tonight since it was featured on PW – I was looking for something to make for dinner before I left work so I could stop at the store on the way home.
This recipe was delicious and very different from other soups I’ve made. Like PW, I used half-and-half (I had heavy cream, but decided to cut back on the calories a bit). However, I DID add the cornstarch/water mixture because I like my creamy soups a little on the thicker side. In fact, I next time I would add another carrot and stalk of celery, just to give it a bit more “meat.” (I chopped my carrots and celery VERY fine – much smaller than PW’s pics and next time would make them a bit chunkier like hers.)
Finally, I added some thyme like a few other reviewers suggested because it almost tasted like it was missing a little something at the end. That was just the ticket! It was very good and satisfying for this cold winter month. Thanks, Alicia!
goodwync on 2.2.2010
Don’t even bother to make this…unless you’re going to DOUBLE the recipe!!! It is amazing in taste and ease or preparation. Novice cooks might be put off by the long list of ingredients but they’re simple ingredients that add up to SO MUCH WONDERFUL FLAVOR!!! My husband isn’t a mushroom fan and he ate 2 bowls at one sitting, thus the recommendation to make twice as much. I didn’t and now I have none to heat and eat later…
I will make it again and soon!
Betsy on 2.3.2010
I love mushrooms, too!!! Love, Love, Love…I can’t wait to try this recipe this weekend! Thanks for sharing!
MontanaMom on 2.3.2010
I made this last night….and WOW….so delish! Thank you!
khrundell on 2.3.2010
can’t wait to try this! i loooove mushrooms!
You must be logged in to post a comment.