21 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
missylaneous on 6.2.2010




This cake is so good, it may be a sin. It’s a bit complicated (I had to keep double-checking the recipe to see what I was supposed to be doing with my strawberries) but none of the steps is particularly hard. Keeping my fingers out of the frosting bowl? That was hard.
theredhouse on 6.7.2010




This is one delicious cake! Moist, flavorful, beautiful… It was devoured by family and friends in no time flat! I used lower-fat ingredients like lite sour cream and neutchafel instead of cream cheese, but it didn’t compromise the taste or texture at all.
The recipe was pretty simple, but there are lots of steps so you really should read through the recipe before you begin in order to allow enough time for each step.
I will definitely make this again and again.
tracyanne78 on 6.11.2010




This is definitely a keeper! This cake tastes absolutely delicious. I did make one change though. I didn’t have any cream cheese in the house but I had a tub of cool whip. I used that as frosting instead of making the cream cheese icing. Next time I will try it with the cream cheese icing but the cool whip worked great.
ssimm411 on 6.22.2010




Made it today in my several week long testing of cake recipes for an upcoming family reunion. It’s fabulous! The only thing I did differently was use a 9″ springform pan instead of an 8″ cake pan. Thanks, Ree!
Exarzun on 6.23.2010




The second I saw this cake I had to try it! However, after three attempts at it, I was stymied. All three came out more then edible, and were finished without hesitation, but the cake bit itself never came out to my satisfaction. Each time it was heavy and brick like, not the dense fluffyness that it was supposed to be! The frosting and strawberry’s came out amazing though, and more then compensated for it.
I’m quite prepared to say that it was all my fault and not the recipe’s at all, but after three attempts I’m stumped as to what I was doing wrong.
brittney on 6.25.2010




This is a really beautiful cake, but it definitely requires a large group to consume it!
tifferrific on 7.5.2010




I just made this for the first time on July 3rd for a fiesta that I went to. It was a huge hit, so I made one yesterday too for the 4th of July and I decorated it with blueberries and strawberries to look like the American Flag. It was great!! So good and delicious, and scrumptious, and amazing! Make it, make it now!! You won’t be sorry.
jenng on 7.9.2010




This cake was delicious! I made it last year and now that strawberries are in season will definetly make it again.
katandgrace on 7.14.2010




Absolutely amazing!!! I made this for a family dinner and the recipe was requested by everyone. So very good!
steeplechaser29 on 7.18.2010




I made this cake twice. Once for my daughter’s birthday in November and then just yesterday for the bridal shower I hosted for my sister.
I thought the cake was really good. Though as someone else mentioned, it’s not quite as light and fluffy as I would have liked. But I was reluctant to use more of a ‘normal’ style cake because I worried that it wouldn’t stand up to the strawberries.
The one thing I wasn’t so fond of with this cake was the frosting. It was so overly sweet, I thought. I’m sure for some, it was great, but if you tend to not like frosting or find it too sweet, this frosting will likely be too sweet and rich for you.
But, I have the perfect substitution for you! Yesterday I used this frosting from TK instead: http://tastykitchen.com/recipes/recipes/desserts/whipped-cream-cream-cheese-frosting/
And it was PERFECT!! It was sweet, but not too sweet, and the flavor was great! I highly recommend this cake with the whipped cream cream cheese frosting!
Everyone at the bridal shower loved it! (well, not that you can expect them to be honest!)
Thanks for the great idea and recipe, PW!
You must be logged in to post a review.





31 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
CajunKate on 7.17.2009
I made this for our Fourth of July celebration. It was super easy to make. So delicious and very pretty on the cake stand. It really does taste like strawberry shortcake, too!
For me, the icing was a bit too sweet but I’m not into super sweet desserts. Everyone else thought it was great, especially my husband. Still next time I might cut back on the powdered sugar in the icing and see how that turns out.
Nonetheless, this is a great cake which I will be using at tailgating events in the fall when the weather cools off. I KNOW it will be a winner!
mrspettigrew on 7.17.2009
I made this yesterday 7/16 for my sons birthday. This is one of the best cakes I’ve ever made. Mrs.Ree sure knows how to cook&bake. I can’t wait till she comes out with a cookbook.
This cake gets moister the longer it sits and it is much better once its been in the refrigerator for a few hours.
My 8 yr. old gives it two thumbs up and I give it 5 mitts.
brigidc111 on 7.19.2009
I have made this several times since posted in May-it is a winner! IMO, it is better than ‘real’ strawberry shortcake. It gets 5 mitts from me, family and friends-thanks for an awesome update on a classic.
nika on 7.19.2009
I made this for my grandfather’s 70th birthday!! My entire family loved this cake!! I have a feeling that it will be requested every strawberry season!
carisle on 7.19.2009
I made this tonight to bring over to some friends’ house. It’s all gone! It was sssooo good! Was easy to make, tastes delicious, and everyone loves it. What more could you ask for!
Andrea on 7.24.2009
I made this for my birthday last month. It was a hit!
rtjenki on 7.28.2009
I made this when you first posted in on the PW site. I made it for a family picnic and it was a huge hit. I personally especially loved it and ate way to much.
brittney on 7.31.2009
I made this cake for a dinner party and it was a wonderful success – thanks Ree!
franknhenry on 7.31.2009
such a wonderful cake – we made it this summer for our dog’s 18th birthday. At 18, you’ve gotta celebrate with a cake even if it is your dog! Not sure how much the dog liked it, but we all did!
bpo21 on 8.4.2009
I made this recipe and it turned out great I do have to say that the icing was also a bit sweet for me, I cut it with some lemon juice & lemon zest and it was great! I also added lemon to the strawberries…. yum. Thanks for the great recipe, again!
You must be logged in to post a comment.