10 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
The Hill Country Cook on 5.28.2011




Oh em gee. I knew I had to make it as soon as I saw it. Just as moist, sticky, and gooey as promised. I’m going to go run now. Bye. ![]()
(I really don’t run, but even talking about running makes me feel better. Maybe I’ll have another piece.)
whatsnextgirls on 5.29.2011




Darn you PW! I saw this on your blog when I was in the mood to bake. It is as gooy and yummy as promised and wonderful as long as you don’t think about all the badness in it! I made it in three smaller pans to share some…
Sheena on 6.21.2011




Soon as I seen this cake I just knew I had to give it a try. WOW..this cake was a huge hit with my family. Great Recipe. A piece of this goes great with a ice cold glass of Milk
lavenia on 6.23.2011




Wow made this for my husband to share with a group of friends and they have gone NUTS over it!!! I agree with Ree I may make it in my sheet cake pan next time though.
loosepurls on 7.5.2011




I made it for a work potluck. Huge hit!! It’s really rich, so making it in the sheet cake pan worked really well!! I love anything that sounds like it came out of an old church cookbook!
Stephanie Deal on 7.18.2011




Oh my giddy aunt. This is absolutely divine!! It is really rich, but oh so fabulous and very easy to make.
christyleeb on 8.10.2011




Wow, I’m almost speechless (almost) with the amazingness of this cake. For reals.
TheJoyfulGinger on 11.8.2011




This got mixed reviews from the crowd. Some raved it was the best cake they’d ever had, others couldn’t even finish a single slice. I thought it was OK. In any case, there is still half a pan left over. Not a good sign for desserts.
You must be logged in to post a review.






13 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
JustCooking (Angela) on 5.22.2011
I could feel my hips getting bigger just by reading the ingredients! Can’t wait to try this!
hellosal on 5.22.2011
Four cups of sugar and eleven Milky Way Bars!!! Holy Man Pioneer Woman! Even though I know that I could never bring myself to make a recipe with that much sugar I am secretly hoping it will be served at a dinner party one evening where the pressure of being in polite company will force me to stop at a respectable one piece.
The Newlywed Chefs on 5.22.2011
OH. my. goodness. This recipe sounds out-of-control good!!
Patty on 5.23.2011
omg! this cake might…just be….death by chocolate…
adeline on 5.23.2011
OMG…..I thought maybe 3-4 bars !!
the picture looks good enough to lick off the computer screen, that way you’re sitting down when you pass out !!
YEP…I’m going to make this TODAY after I pick up my g’kids from school, they are going to love unwrapping ALL that candy !
THANKS
cheekyboots on 5.23.2011
Do you think it could be made with butter instead? I dislike margarine.
porthos on 5.24.2011
This recipe looks delicious, but it weighs it at about 800 calories per serving. Yikes. Even at 16 servings, it tops 600 calories each. Too rich for my blood.
ShannonMC on 5.27.2011
Cheekyboots, I just made this cake and I used butter. I dislike margarine, oleo, too. The cake is out of this world awesome. I was actually short one milky way so I used 7 1/2 in the cake and 2 1/2 in the frosting. I couldn’t wait to make it just for one more candy bar. Oh PW! It is crazy good. Thank you.
Porthos – Shame on you making us who want to devour it and pretend it has no calories because we drink it with a diet coke feel bad.
pennynoel on 6.1.2011
This will be the next potluck cake I make! Looks delicious and is really fun with all those candy bars!!
lavenia on 6.23.2011
Just made this cake. YUMMY 10 MITTENS!!!!!!
You must be logged in to post a comment.