32 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
PamFromNY on 5.3.2011




While these were definitely a treat, I can’t handle too much of their sweetness, so cut them small if you’re not into very sweet desserts.
Also, my pan was slightly smaller than 9×13 and it boiled over in my oven – oops! Use the full 9×13 pan.
mollyblue on 5.4.2011




I took these to a party, and everyone loved them! They’re very rich, but so good!
I baked in a 9×9 pan and cut into 16 pieces. I also used only one bag of caramel (~40 pieces) and it was plenty.
nursesarah on 5.7.2011




Yes, very rich but very good! Just cut them small and you’re in for a huge treat! Love the layer of chewy carmel in the middle…just put them over the edge, in a good way!
PlanoSheila on 5.7.2011




Yum! Easy and delicious! The hardest part was unwrapping the little caramels. I have no patience for such things. But these are worth it!
kendracooks on 5.8.2011




I loved these- my husband said they should be called diabetes brownies… Definitely sweet. We had them when company came over, and I took the leftovers on little plates to women in the neighborhood, I was very popular after that. The caramel is my favorite part.
bowmanh23 on 5.8.2011




I made these for a Mother’s Day Luncheon at school and then I made them for my mother in law and our family for Mother’s Day. These are moist and rich, just the way you like a brownie to be. At my mother in law’s I heated the brownie up and then served it with vanilla ice cream. There were no leftovers. Thankfully, no one got naked!
Jillian A on 5.8.2011




Everyone in my family loves these Killer Brownies! I baked them in a 9×13” pan and cut them into 24 bars and they were still super rich. I looked at the Dorothy Lane website as well to get ideas for more flavor combinations! Use the “Evil Caramel Sauce” from Sally Darling on here and you won’t be disappointed!
jenng on 5.11.2011




I must start by saying that I’m not a cake mix girl. I don’t like box cakes and think they taste fake. However using the mix in a different way totally worked. My family and coworker loved these:) Thanks for sharing!
creeksidecottage on 5.13.2011




I have never thought a chocolate dessert was too rich, but maybe these are a little. They would have been better with about 1/2 the carmel and I wouldn’t have to have unwrapped so many of those little jobbers!
You must be logged in to post a review.






18 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
chicken34 on 4.30.2011
oh my gosh this looks so good… well it IS the first day of may so i guess i DO deserve this… hahe i will make it- muhaha! utterly decadent lookin’ though
on 4.30.2011
WOW! This sounds great! I will be trying this very soon! Thank you
Dorothy of OR on 5.1.2011
You had me at naked! YUMMY!
misskoren on 5.1.2011
I dream of the killer brownies at Dorthy Lane! My husband and I moved away from Dayton but the Killer Brownie will forever be in my heart
melwell on 5.1.2011
This is my FAVORITE recipe! My mom taught me how to make it when I was a kid. She calls them German Chocolate Bars. She dots the second half of the cake recipe across the carmel and chocolate chips instead of rolling it out to cover the top. One time I tried making this one my own and I MADE the cake instead of following the directions. Not all was lost, but I learned my lesson.
barb on 5.1.2011
and now I don’t have to dream of the Dorothy Lane Market evil killer brownies. Thanks to you Ree I can now make something that is so very close to the real thing………….my hips thank you NOT!!
frannabelle on 5.1.2011
Oh man, this recipe is ringing my fillings! I have NEVER seen a brownie like this before. I’ve never been to Dayton and never met Dorothy Lane, (sob!) but thank you, Ree for bringing this lovely treat into my life! Later, Gators! Gonna go stun my family with this one!
cait on 5.1.2011
I’m going to make these for my friend for the day after her wedding. She’s been working really hard to get in shape for her big day and has been disciplined enough to give up cakes and sweets completely until she eats the wedding cake. I’ve promised her something yummy delivered to her honeymoon suite as a reward for her perseverance, and these look perfect!
mikewas on 5.1.2011
Ohio must be home to killer brownies. West Point Market in Akron Ohio has them too — several variants e.g. caramel, raspberry, mint …
I have to give this recipe a try since they are 10 hours away now.
We’d get box lunches for meetings, they were labelled with the type sandwich but nothing else. Folks in the know would choose the heavy boxes because they had the killer brownies!
tessks on 5.2.2011
These look fantastic! The name is what caught my eye though. My sister has a classic brownie recipe (straight brownie, no extra stuff) that has been dubbed ‘Better Than Sex Brownies,’ or ‘Nutless Wonders.’ I’ll have to steal it from her to post here. =) Once I’m allowed to eat sugar again, these sinful chocolate/caramel ones might be at the top of my list of indulgences!
You must be logged in to post a comment.