4 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
Elizabeth's Dutch Oven on 5.18.2010
Was a little too rich for me, even as a peanut butter lover. But I would definitely make it again!
The Sugar Tree on 5.20.2010
Fantastic dish. Yes, it is rich, so we just cut smaller pieces. My husband is a huge peanut butter pie fan, and he said this tops his list. THANKS!
jaxanahalf on 8.11.2010
A M A Z I N G! Made this and brought it to a family weekend away and it was devoured. I even caught people sneaking it out of the fridge for a midnight treat well after everyone said they were stuffed. I would always make room for this amazing pie! Easy to make too 
srenaek on 2.24.2011
I’m a huge peanut butter pie fan, and this is absolutely fantastic! It is a little rich, but just cut a smaller piece and it’s all good The fact that it is super fast and easy to make, makes it even better!
You must be logged in to post a review.
9 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
mrsq on 11.11.2009
Soooooo rich. But if you like peanut butter, you’ll love this simple dish.
surggreys07 on 11.26.2009
As soon as I took this out of the fridge it looked just like your picture! Almost gone! It’s very rich but very good!! Even my mother in law thats not too keen on peanut butter loved it!
amanda on 1.6.2010
I am trying to figure out where I can hide the pie so I can have it all to myself! Very rich, very good!
Amanda on 2.11.2010
I thought it was perfect! Though I have not met a dessert that was too rich for me.
nicole33 on 2.21.2010
Just made this for a dinner last night… Delicious! Everyone loved it. It’s a little rich but I had no problem eating a whole slice.
memphisbelle on 3.18.2010
I made this for a co-workers birthday. I don’t like peanut butter – it takes me forever to get through a jar but this pie was fabulous! I melted some chocolate and drizzled it on top after the pie was cooled and it made for a very pretty presentation. It was also so easy! Great recipe
megwilson06 on 3.24.2010
I freaking love peanut butter pie! I use to work at a bbq restaurant in TN. They had a similiar recipe. I think they added a little milk, and crushed reese’s peanut butter cups. oh man, is it good! I also like to add a little whip cream & more crushed reese’s on top.
Chaney D. on 3.26.2010
This is VERY YUMMY! I cheated and used a premade oreo crust and it was SO easy. I had a nice glass of cold milk with it and it slid right down.
kendraanne on 8.18.2010
Wonderful!! I made this for my sister-in-laws birthday because she didn’t want cake. This is a super easy recipe! I drizzled some melted chocolate chips on top prior to serving.
You must be logged in to post a comment.