8 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
danmar7 on 11.26.2010
Easy to make, but for my first roll in a long time, I failed to follow the cooling directions, so the cake wouldn’t roll up when I spread the filling. But it still tasted great.
laurasmom on 11.11.2010
Delicious! I had never made a pumpkin roll and it was so easy thanks to your easy directions! Will definitely make again. Thanks.
lillieknits on 10.22.2010
I made this recipe for a group of ladies. It was my first attmept at a rolled cake. Mine wasn’t nearly as pretty. I actually made two. The first time I used wax paper, but it stuck around the edges. Next I used parchment paper, and it flopped off much quicker than I was ready for. I really dislike cream cheese icing, so I used the Best Frosting Ever recipe instead. That may have partially been the reason it didn’t roll as neatly.
Hanna Denton on 10.18.2010
Made it this weekend for the extended family and got LOTS of compliments! My first experience with the roll was a great one- you’re right, it does look harder than it really is! Will try the frozen cutting method next time, as mine was a little messy, even after refrigerating. Thanks!
katn85 on 9.29.2010
absolutely delicious! This was my first “roll” and was so pleased with how well it came out. I made one last week, and will be making another this afternoon 
11 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
baileysrule on 4.16.2013
I have made pumpkin rolls for years and I can say to those of you that talk about the roll cracking……no problem just put some powder sugar and a few nuts and you won’t be able to notice.
walkinwalkoutcattle on 10.9.2010
I think the pumpkin has quite a bit of natural fats in it. (I could be wrong though!)
Juanita on 9.23.2010
kristen02,
It’s actually not difficult at all! Please don’t let that stop you from making it. And even if it doesn’t look quite perfect (mine don’t always turn out perfect either) it will still taste amazing!
kristen02 on 9.22.2010
I knew a woman who made this regularly and it’s sooo good! However, I haven’t gotten up the courage to make it, because rolling and unrolling the cake is daunting to me.
llhh on 9.22.2010
thanks for answering the oil question. i tried a recipe like this once before that used 1 cup of oil! i didn’t care for it because it tasted greasy. i will definately make this recipe, and hope it comes out as beautiful as yours.