22 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
cupoverflows on 11.27.2010




Easy to make, super flaky, and I have two more in the freezer! My only complaint is that it didn’t roll out as big as I needed so my crimping wasn’t very pretty. Not sure if that was my fault for not portioning the dough right or if I should separate it in two next time… Or roll it thinner… In any case, it was delish.
abigailleigh on 12.8.2010




I loved this recipe – I made it super easy by mixing it in my food processor. This recipe is just like my grandmother’s recipe with the exception of the vinegar. Will definitely be using this recipe again and again…and again.
terrilw on 12.18.2010




This was the best pie crust I’ve ever made. It was great after freezing. It even still turned out flaky after working with it a lot unlike other crusts when you have to be very gentle with them.
amberwooten on 1.3.2011




This truly is the perfect pie crust…and hard to mess up too! This was my very first attempt at making my own pie crust and boy was it a huge success. It was perfectly flaky, but also held together once you started scooping and slicing. I will definitely be making my own pie crust from now on…delicious!
valentinegirlxo on 1.5.2011




It is just perfect! I will never eat another pie crust other than this again.
theladymcarthur on 2.19.2011




I’ve always been terrified to make pie because I didn’t know how to make the crust but because of this recipe I don’t have that fear anymore. I’ve made a chicken pot pie as well as a french silk pie using it and both turned out amazing and so tasty. This is so easy and foolproof that anyone could do it. I loved it!
mnmamajen on 3.10.2011




I’ve never been able to make pie crust that wasn’t tough. This crust was wonderful!
Lacey Maurer on 6.24.2011




I love this pie crust. I love that it is super flaky and I love how light and airy it is, not too dense like some pie crusts. I am also amazed at how easy this is to make. I’ll never buy pre-made pie crust again. I used this pie crust to make chicken pot pie, and everyone agreed that the crust was delicious.
ninali on 9.9.2011




I read through the original blog post comments and I saw the author of the recipe mention that it was helpful to have all the ingredients cold…and its the truth. It really helped, because the first batch I made was extremely sticky and hard to separate. Also, definitely give it time to thaw…if its crumbling when you try and roll it needs more time to thaw. I found between 10 to 15 worked well.
You must be logged in to post a review.






18 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
dblamon on 11.27.2009
This is the flakiest crust I’ve eaten. Good enough to eat without the pie (but who wants to waste a good pie). Easy to make – don’t overwork the dough. Chilling keeps the shortening from blending too much and improves the flakiness.
notbragginjustcantcook on 1.12.2010
I’ve made six pie crusts with this recipe. First time in my 52 years on earth that I’m making anything of the sort. I even chill the bowls now and it turns out perfect every time. As promised!
Chuck on 2.8.2010
I’m admittedly not a baker nor do I really like baking, but this crust was easy and used it for leftover turkey pot pies. I hope to use the rest for a quiche maybe. This is definitely easy and handy.
skyblue on 2.18.2010
I’ve been using this pie crust for all of my pies for the past 6ish months. It is the perfect texture and taste for sweet pies such as blueberry, apple, or strawberry. It is light and flaky without being too dry or bland. I love that I can make extras and throw them in the freezer for future pie making. Wonderful recipe!
cruisinmom on 2.18.2010
This was the first pie crust I ever tried to make and it just may be the last : ) Super easy and very good. Everyone loves my pumpkin pie and the crust makes it superb!
Courtney on 4.12.2010
Looks like your friend Sylvia and my family must have been hanging out! My great-grandmother’s pie crust recipe is almost exactly the same! Great bakers….bake alike! I’m sure this one is absolutely fabulous.
djrepp on 7.11.2010
I use the same recipe but without the egg
and vinegar.
djrepp on 7.11.2010
I guess I need to work on the profile picture! Looks just like a bunch of sand! Anyway, I will be anxious to try your recipe. My grandmother’s was very similar if not identical.
ccsick on 8.26.2010
All of these wonderful comments but nobody has rated the pie crust? Too bad!!
Jack on 9.6.2010
Made an apple pie with this recipe last night.
All the “flaky” press this recipe gets is legit. This is straight-up super flaky crust.
It is also loaded with shortening. I checked Alton Brown’s recipe and he uses a combination of butter and lard, but in no where near the quantities that Sylvia recommends. (Not a criticism, just an observation.)
Great crust, super easy to make. Loved it.
Hugs to Sylvia.
You must be logged in to post a comment.