22 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
WenDee Riffe on 11.1.2010




Oh my word~~~when I took my first bite of this cheesecake I thought I was eating at the Cheesecake Factory!!! This is an awesome tasting recipe as well as an easy one to make!!!! Keep up the great recipes farm girleeee!!!!!
shellsonvancouverisland on 11.4.2010




Argh …. I overcooked this in the 90 minutes it was in the oven. The top became very dark. It tastes great though and I look forward to trying it again. It was incredibly creamy but very soft and hard to serve nicely.
So I am going to amend my initial review. This turned out much better after a few hours and after some discussion with those more familiar with cheesecakes I believe the problem with how soft it was would be solved by letting it set for the suggested 24 hours.
The flavor was great and it was very creamy, a result of the hot water bath …… so if you are going to skip the bath, you can, but the resulting cake may be less creamy.
Someone compared it to a Cheesecake Factory cake which was a great compliment as it was my very first cheesecake.
tracyo on 11.6.2010




This is a wonderful recipe. I have always been intimidated by cheesecake recipes but my husband loves them. I decided to try this recipe to see if I could do it and it turned out great! It wasn’t hard to make at all. He is so happy and so am I. I plan to make it again for Thanksgiving. The pumpkin is not overpowering…just right! Thank you so much for this recipe!
rockymtngal on 11.14.2010




This turned out great! It was the first cheesecake I’ve ever made so I was really intimidated. But the instructions were easy and it came out scrumptious. Thanks!
Cathy on 11.15.2010




Oops didn’t see that the reviews tab is different from the comments tab…made this yesterday for my hubby. The only thing I did differently was to make my own puree from garden pumkin. He said it’s his new favorite
.
rosiesnow on 11.15.2010




This was my first cheesecake and it turned out perfect! I was nervous because after an hour I checked on it and it was already very golden but I let it go until an hour and thirty minutes and it was wonderful! I did use a little less cloves and nutmeg just because I’m not a huge fan of the strong flavors. This was my test run for Thanksgiving and it will be a hit!
windruffle on 11.17.2010




Just took this baby out of the oven – smells wonderful, great texture and no cracks! Too bad I have a milk and egg allergy or I’d dig in right now! This was my first cheesecake. Thanks for the wonderful instructions. Serving it up tomorrow at our early Thanksgiving dinner. Can’t wait to hear what my Mom (in-law) says about it!
marysunshyn on 11.22.2010




I made two slight changes – I used a pre-made gluten free ginger cookie in the crust, and I used rice flour instead of all purpose flour. I’m so glad I took the gamble on those subsitutions.
This is Excellent! I hadn’t made a cheesecake in years, and I was a little nervous about making this one, but the instructions were detailed, and I didn’t have any trouble. And the end result was AMAZING! The flavor and texture were both delightful. My family finished it off in no time, and that’s the real evidence that it was great.
I’ll be making this recipe again on Wednesday, for our Thanksgiving dinner!
amyellebull on 11.22.2010




This is a great substitute for pumpkin pie on Thanksgiving, for those of you that like traditional flavors but hate routine! My family really liked the cheesecake, especially the crust.
amusebooks on 11.24.2010




This really is a great cheesecake. If you have never used a water bath before, be very careful that you do not let your water get higher than the lowest spot of your tinfoil or water can get into the area around the pan and affect the crust a little.
I also reccomend starting this early in the day; mine took several hours to come to room temperature! I wound up setting an alarm and putting it into the fridge at 1 a.m.
You must be logged in to post a review.







16 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
Allison at Novice Life on 10.30.2010
This looks wonderful!
cylina on 11.1.2010
what size of spring form pan is this for?
afarmgirlsdabbles on 11.1.2010
Cylina – “Preheat oven to 350°. Prepare a 9″ springform pan by lightly spraying with cooking spray.”
carolinabelle on 11.1.2010
This looks divine and I can’t wait to try this for Thanksgiving.
lesia on 11.1.2010
Looks great–love all things pumpkin!!
Heather Christo on 11.1.2010
That is beautiful! and GREAT photography
mimi1214 on 11.9.2010
I usually purchase one from Cheesecake Factory – I think I’ll try and make my own this year!
melodyc on 11.14.2010
I’ve just been requested to make this for Thanksgiving. As if I’m going to argue!! Looking forward to it!
Christiane M.B. on 11.14.2010
I made this today! I halved the recipe, made the pumpkin purèe from scratch and skipped the sour cream since I didn’t have any, but didn’t miss it since the taste was absolutely superb. I used the same amount of spices as for the original measurements and loved the spicyness of the cake.
Cathy on 11.15.2010
I made this yesterday for the hubster who loves cheesecake. I used some pumpkin from the garden and pureed it in the processor. He said he thinks it’s his new favorite.
You must be logged in to post a comment.