21 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
melrr on 10.7.2010




I made almost 40 cupcakes with this recipe and they are DEEEEEEELICIOUS! I didn’t use the glaze, but will probably try it if I make an actual cake. Thank you for sharing this recipe!
ifyouloveitfeedit on 10.24.2010




This cake is SOOO moist and delicious. The buttermilk glaze makes a huge difference! I baked it yesterday for my husband’s birthday. Mine looked a little bit frumpy because I was rushed for time and assembled and iced it while it was still a tiny bit warm, but it tasted amazing!
This is definitely a keeper! Thanks for the wonderful recipe!
shoppin4sophia on 12.21.2010




I made this over the weekend – it was AMAZING. The only thing I might do differently next time is to poke the warm cakes with a fork before pouring the buttermilk glaze over the top so that the glaze doesn’t roll over to the edges as much. Excellent recipe. I will make this again and again.
basloane on 2.26.2011




I’ve made a lot of carrot cakes over the years, and this is the best recipe I’ve ever made. I made it in a 9×13 pan and skipped the glaze, and it was fantastic.
cheriephotography on 3.8.2011




Everyone said it was so tasty!! I’ll be sticking to this recipe for next time I make carrot cake!
landynlogan on 3.12.2011




This cake was a huge hit, so moist and delicious. I made it again the other day but did them as cupcakes and they were delicious. I did poke holes in the cupcakes because the glaze was just drizzling off them. I also left them in the cupcake pan and it all seemed to work out wonderfully. I will def. be making this again and again.
1skipper on 4.18.2011




This Cake is Fantastic and was a HUGE hit. You could eat the glaze all by itself. Yummy! The cake is moist and I did use a reviewers idea and poke holes with a fork before adding the glaze and it worked great! I will be making this again and again.
Thanks for sharing…it is the best ever!!
lhath08 on 4.25.2011




Now that I’ve made (and tasted this cake) I have to thank you for the recipe & thank the other reviewers for such high recommendations.
This cake is delicious, both cake & frosting and was fairly simple to make. I used the buttermilk glaze (making my own lemon juice + milk sub)
The only question I have- is that I had pieces of cake falling off when I removed the wax paper, despite having sprayed both sides. It was a little diveted. That could be bc of the moistness or because it’s a carrot cake & they all do that. But the taste made up for it!
ilovedoxies on 7.4.2011




GREAT cake! The only thing I changed was that I doubled the cinnamon. LOVED LOVED LOVED the buttermilk glaze…just an all around great cake. This one is a keeper..will make it over and over again.
marcia snapp on 7.23.2011




I love this cake! This is my favorite carrot cake recipe! I always make it in a 9×13 pan with the glaze. Fantastic!
You must be logged in to post a review.






10 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
whitschex on 1.17.2010
FANTASTIC! This cake was so moist and had such great flavor. For my first stab at carrot cake, I’m very happy I tried this one!
Joy A on 2.25.2010
Really good cake! Made it today and it is so moist and yummy! Thanks for the recipe!
melrr on 10.7.2010
This really IS the best carrot cake ever.
nishaco on 12.6.2010
I made this yesterday for my Mom’s 78th birthday and it was a huge hit! It has now been requested that I bring this for our family Christmas gathering. It really is the best carrot cake EVER!
basloane on 2.26.2011
I’ve made a lot of carrot cakes over the years, and this is the best recipe I’ve ever made. I made it in a 9×13 pan and skipped the glaze, and it was fantastic.
ksj1 on 4.11.2011
This really is the best carrot cake! I skipped the buttermilk glaze, and it was still wonderful. It’s VERY moist and stayed that way for almost a week on my counter under a glass dome. And it lasted a whole week since it’s just my husband and me.
penpen on 9.12.2011
This is very similar to a recipe I use regularly for carrot cake. The only difference–I use golden raisins along with pineapple and coconut, but not the glaze. I’m willing to try sometime. Thanks.
Carla Walker on 10.11.2011
Such a yummy carrot cake. My first carrot cake bake and was so worth it!!!
ellachootrain on 10.19.2011
YUM!!!
IUHoosiergirl on 4.7.2012
I am disappointed in this cake. I LOVE LOVE LOVE the taste but the presentation is awful. I was requested to bring a dessert for Easter tomorrow and I thought this carrot cake would be a hit. I’ve made it 3 times today and it’s been a mess every time. IDK what I’m doing wrong??? I first tried in 2 round cake pans, the center sank and I couldn’t stack them. It ended up a goopy mess on my cooling rack. I made again in a 9×13 and the same thing happend. ?? Can anyone help??
You must be logged in to post a comment.