12 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
luvmychaos on 12.20.2012
So unbelievably good! I was drawn to this recipe for easy instructions and short(er),than most, proof time. It took a little longer than I thought to get the dough made but I’m a poor judge of how long things will take to cool,dissolve,etc.I followed directions as outlined but threw everything in my stand mixer with a dough hook for the mixing/kneading part. The only change I made was adding butter to the skillet,like some other recipes suggested. They came out like perfect puffs of buttery perfection! Oh and as a side note,due to my poor timing judgment,I actually had to leave while they were rising to get kids from school so they rose for closer to 2 1/2 hrs with no effect on the finished product at all! Just thought other scattered moms,would appreciate that added plus!
magpiesvt on 9.6.2012
Mine definitely were more like hockey pucks. Shucks! I’ll stick to Thomas’ for now
alwayssmile on 6.13.2011
I used half whole wheat flour and these turned out great. Very easy. My husband LOVES these! Will definitely make again! I also had to cook mine for less time than stated. I recommend for others to start checking them after 4 minutes.
cicadagirl on 4.15.2011
Hrm. Not sure what went wrong, but these were a COMPLETE failure despite following the recipe to the letter. First of all, the dough was SO dry and crumbly that I could barely get it to stick together. I ended up having to sprinkle a bit of water onto it to get it even close to knead-able. Then, the muffin rounds barely rose at all, even after more than an hour in a nice warm place. And finally, trying to cook them for 10 minutes each side? As if! Doing that, I just wound up with black muffins and a distinct odor of burnt popcorn in my kitchen. I had to cook them for less than 5 minutes a side, on low heat, to keep them from burning…and still basically ended up with flat, dry, hockey pucks.
*sigh*
heidimay18 on 4.4.2011
I didn’t think these were very much work at all. I’m not a fan of english muffins, but my husband loves them so I thought I would try them. I loved these! These will definitely be a regular at our house. I made these with 3 c. whole wheat flour and 2 1/2 c. white flour.
9 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
dianam on 2.8.2011
My family and friends absolutely loved these! I tweaked the recipe to add 3 cups whole wheat flour, 2 1/2 cups regular flour since I like whole wheat muffins best. I also reduced the temp and cooking time in the skillet, it may have been my skillet.
This will be a “make this recipe again” in our house! Yummy!
Delicious & Divine on 2.4.2011
This recipe is amazing! The only thing I tweaked is the temperature of the skillet when they are being cooked. They got very dark after just 4 minutes in a medium temperature skillet, so I lowered the temperature and watched them carefully. Perhaps it was the pan I was using. Otherwise, these turned out fantastic!
ecourtney on 2.4.2011
Wondering if anyone has tried these with margarine and rice or soy milk for a dairy free version? and did you get good results?
Thanks!
Susan on 2.1.2011
1/4oz of an ounce of yeast = 2 1/4tsp or 1 envelope of pre-measured yeast.
Sharon on 2.1.2011
Does anyone know what 1/4 ounce weight translates to measurement wise?