4 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
Dede on 3.11.2018
Absolutely fantastic. If you love key lime pie you will LOVE this cake. May it the first time for friends for her birthday. In the process of making 2nd one for my neighbor’s birthday. Definitely “tart & tangy” but oh so yummy!
terrilw on 8.4.2010
Terrific! Next time though I would only use half of the sugar bath and half of the frosting.
Sharon on 5.20.2010
I made this wonderful cake for a Christmas 2009 get together. It was well recieved and I was requested to bring it for Christmas 2010. I made the candied lime. It was a bit time consuming but added so much to the presentation. I could have easily halved the quanity of frosting and still had plenty. As it was, I used the remainder on sugar cookies. This cake was a yummy delight!
homegirl on 5.18.2010
I made this and it’s awe-some-uh. I want to live in a world made of Baking in Boots Key Lime Cake.
30 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
happymomof4 on 4.17.2011
I have made this twice….it is my son’s favorite cake!!
Kelsey Barnard on 6.30.2010
Homegirl- What a sweet comment. And it made me laugh so much. Thank you!
Terrilw-So glad you liked it and that you figured out what works for you. Thank you for commenting!
kellysahm-that is crazy! Congrats to her and thank you so much for the feedback!
kellysahm on 6.30.2010
My oldest daughter made this cake for our county fair, she made the auction with it! It brought her $500! Thank you for this recipe!
terrilw on 5.7.2010
Oh my goodness!!! The cake alone was wonderful but when you put the sugar bath and frosting on, it is heaven on a plate. Incredibly delicious!!! (I had to bake mine for 85 minutes and also used only 1/2 recipe of frosting which was plenty.)
homegirl on 2.5.2010
I made this and it’s awesome-uh. I want to live in a world made of Baking in Boots Key Lime Cake.