4 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
Aims on 7.17.2011
I have never made candy before and had no problem following this recipe. As long as you adhere to the steps exactly, you should have no problem. The texture was perfect, but the flavour wasn’t near chocolatey enough for me. I wonder now if what I thought was a 2oz weight of chocolate was actually not a weight at all or if I just didn’t use a chocolate that was good enough quality.
My first attempt turned out fudge like in consistency, but very sweet with just a hint of chocolate. I will try it again with a few tweaks.
Laura2 on 4.19.2011
The taste of this fudge is awesome. I thought I beat it long enough…but I didn’t. It didn’t stand up enough…but nothing wasted…me and my daughter warmed it back up and drizzled it over ice cream.
I told Brooke (daughter) who is the fudge lover. I would try again in a couple days to make the fudge right! I love the creamy smooth texture, can’t wait to try it again…Thanks for the recipe!
liulady on 1.26.2011
I can’t IMAGINE how the above reviewer had the experience she did even WITHOUT a candy thermometer!?!
I was SO excited about this recipe. But, beware! This is not an easy recipe to follow and probably not something you want to attempt if you are not somewhat skilled at candy-making. It COMPLETELY flopped for me both times I tried it. And, I followed the directions and temperatures as exactly as I understood them in the recipe. I’ll bet its fantastic when done right, though! But for me…I guess I’ll just have to continue buying the “real thing”
Christianne on 6.5.2010
I don’t have a candy thermometer, but miraculously, my fudge came out perfect! Thanks for providing a real fudge recipe.
11 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
liulady on 1.26.2011
So sorry…I’m new to this and just realized I left a “review” where I should have posted a “comment”. Oops!
liulady on 1.26.2011
I was SO excited about this recipe. But, beware! This is not an easy recipe to follow and probably not something you want to attempt if you are not somewhat skilled at candy-making. It COMPLETELY flopped for me both times I tried it. And, I followed the directions and temperatures as exactly as I understood them in the recipe. I’ll bet its fantastic when done right, though! But for me…I guess I’ll just have to continue buying the “real thing”
strandjss on 10.26.2010
I remember the fudge my father made when I was a little girl. I know he used cocoa and I’m pretty sure it was the old-fashioned Hershey recipe (and maybe this one is too?) BUT….what I really remember and wish I could recreate is the GRITTY TEXTURE that I associate with REAL fudge. Does anyone know what I’m talking about? Will this recipe give me the gritty stuff? I’ve got to try this for Hanukkah – Will post a review once I make it. Thanks
perumbula on 7.13.2010
Lizrosedodd, it sounds like your fudge crystalized, which means the sugar reformed into larger crystals and changed the texture of what the fudge should have been. It should be smooth and creamy when you are done.
Make sure when you make candy that you follow three simple rules:
1. sweat the pan! Leave the lid on for 3-5 minutes after the candy begins to boil.
2. always use a clean spoon. If you stirred the ingredients together before you put the lid on to sweat the pan, get a new spoon. You do not want to mix that dirty spoon with the already over 200 degree syrup in the pan. It will not be pretty.
3. Never ever scrape the pot when you pour out the cooked candy. leave all that stuff clinging to the pot. If you feel it’s a waste, give it to a kid to lick clean.
Those guidelines should help you keep the candy from crystallizing next time you make it.
Now for your question on how long to beat the candy, well that depends on what temperature you started beating at, how warm the room you are beating it is, and a few other things. This time you really have to go by sight. It’s done when it looks like frosting. When you turn the mixer off it should soften and fall back into the bowl but still be thick. For photos showing you what to look for, click the “related blog post” link up above.
Good luck!
lizrosedodd on 12.17.2009
Great recipe. This was my first time to make genuine fudge and I was a little confused during the mixing stage. How long do you beat the mixture? I stayed on speed 6 for what seemed like almost 10 minutes and it never lost the gloss. In fact it became glossier. So I just decided to pour it into the pan but didn’t realize how quickly it became brittle. Once I’d scraped everything into the pan and I tried to press the fudge down it started breaking apart. BUT, the fudge is WONDERFUL! Texture is smooth, but it falls apart easily when cut up, I believe because I didn’t move quicker in the spreading-it-in-the-pan phase. I’m going to try it again, but I’d appreciate any additional tips you can give!