Holiday Monster Cookies

Comments

kathryn on 12.20.2009

This is almost exactly the recipe I made yesterday, although your recipe sounds yummier. We can’t use m&m’s because of dye allergies so I use all chocolate chips. The coconut would be such a great addition so I will try that next time!

annielauree on 12.20.2009

Just when I thought I’d baked my last cookie for the holiday. Now I have to try these, they sound so good.

hjstep on 12.20.2009

These are really great. Everybody has loved them so far. Super easy to make as well. Thanks for posting!

prairieprincess on 12.22.2009

Loved them!!!! And mine looked just like your picture which never happens to me!

irishheart on 12.22.2009

These are absolutely a must-have at Christmas from now on! They were SO easy to make, my little one loved helping me! I doubled the batch and made all the children at pageant practice very happy last night! A real keeper….

jrew on 12.24.2009

These were really yummy, but for some reason mine came out really flat and spread out. Must have been something I did wrong though since the other reviews said they came out perfect. I’ll have to try them again another time.

lizzyr on 12.24.2009

My family tried this recipe on our annual cookie day. Yummy! Chewy, moist, coconut (which is a favorite of mine in cookies). I changed nothing! They will be a standard on cookie day in future years. Thanks for the yummy recipe!

momofg on 12.28.2009

These are great! Nice and chewy, just the way my family likes them. I did not have any coconut flakes but no one complained. Thank you for sharing!

2sail on 12.28.2009

Love these… Turned out just like the picture. My family gobbled them up. Had to make a second batch for company and the neighbors. So good…would make them again, for sure!

Carrie on 1.3.2010

I whipped these up as a thank you gift for a neighbor who plowed our driveway while we were away for Christmas. They were FANTASTIC (even though I left out the coconut…)!

1 2 Next »

You must be logged in to post a comment.

okiemama on 12.2.2010

I made these as soon as I saw the recipe. How could I not, with these ingredients? My husband just laughed as I ate one, two, three, FOUR cookies and then chugged milk. Out of the carton (gasp!) I couldn’t help it. These are what cookies were meant to be. Delicious, irresistable, fattening. I must get the rest out of my house immediately before I enter a sugar coma. Thanks for the recipe!

sk8rvet on 1.7.2011

This is my favorite monster cookie recipe- I think it must be the coconut that makes it especially good! Thanks for sharing.

cookoutsidethebox on 1.25.2011

This is a perfect recipe and the coconut is what sets it apart. My kids are allergic to peanuts and tree nuts, so I substituted sunbutter for the pb and had no problems. Super soft and oh so deliciously dangerous. Unfortunately I down 6 cookies in less than 10 minutes. Thank you for sharing!