11 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
uyzie on 11.7.2010




My boyfriend loved it! He’s requested simply making only the filling– I kind of think he could probably eat a whole bowl of it!
lovetocook on 11.25.2010




Oh, yes it is! This was my first attempt at a homemade pie, and I will never make a different apple pie recipe.
justplainkim on 2.27.2011




Great recipe! Simple and delicious….I have made some much more difficult and complex apple pies…and this one was every bit as good an any I have ever made!
eruthora on 3.14.2011




This really is the best apple pie ever. I’d never made apple pie before and it turned out great! I’m making it again today for Pi day.
Jennifer on 8.7.2011




I’m not a big apple pie person, but I had a request for an apple pie and made this one. It is HEAVENLY! The brown sugar just makes it taste SO GOOD!
dianals on 9.19.2011




I have replaced my go to pie with this one..OMG was this HEAVEN! I am not a huge apple pie fan, well, until now..I used 2 different apples, galas, and Macs, and used more than the recipe calls for ( apples cook down) I wanted it filled to the brim.. I cannot wait to make another!
averywalser on 4.22.2012




This has become my go to apple pie recipe! Delicious every single time and it always turns out great!
You must be logged in to post a review.






11 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
sherylmacnie on 8.30.2009
I’m in an apple pie rut at the moment, this looks great! Am trying it right now.
lottiebay on 9.6.2009
This is absolutely the best tasting Apple pie I ever made! I used the apples from the tree in my front yard instead of Granny Smiths and they are tart, but not quite as juicy. I think next time I make it I will cut the amount of flour a little. but OMG! this was soooo good!
cmac on 9.21.2009
Made this for a weekend getaway with the girls! It lives up to its name and then some! It is absolutely fantastic.
moonflwr (Tai) on 10.25.2009
this pie was yummy! i made it for a dinner party with some friends. the only modification i had to make was to put it back in the oven once it was cooked at 425 degrees for about 10-15 minutes. the bottom of the crust was still a bit doughy.
kristieann718 on 11.16.2009
Delicious!! I could have eaten the entire pie myself.
omgyouguys on 11.30.2009
I made this for Thanksgiving and the whole family loved it! It will be making many future appearances!
mamakaren on 1.24.2010
I made this yesterday to celebrate National Pie Day. It tasted SO good, although mine turned out more like a crisp than a pie. I will be making it again!
carmsie on 2.10.2010
I have been making apple pies for 30 years, and today I decided to try something new!! I have to admit–this pie is better than my tried and true. I hope I will be making this recipe for the next 30 years!! Thank you!
hope515 on 9.22.2010
Thanks for the recipe! I made this on Monday and it was wonderful. I served it warm with vanilla bean ice cream and it got a big thumbs up from everyone.
uyzie on 11.7.2010
The pie was delicious, and looked beautiful. My boyfriend loved the filling so much, he wants me to make it by itself! The only very small thing that I would change is that I’d put just a tad bit less flour in the mix, as it was very thick and heavy, and if you served the pie cold, it felt a little too pasty. Next time, I’m going to try it with only a half cup, to see if it lightens it up a bit.
You must be logged in to post a comment.