4 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
VictoriaDoubleU on 8.18.2011
This was excellent! I too used sour cream since that’s what I had. I did add a bit more sugar since I like things on the sweeter side. I’ll definitely make this again! Thanks so much for sharing.
kenadine87 on 3.25.2011
I made this for my husband’s b-day and he, we, LOVED it! It took about 20 key limes, used fat free condensed milk and didn’t have cream so I used sour cream, but it still turned out so creamy and yummy! The coconut in the crust was awesome! I could have eaten the crust by itself! You might consider mentioning Coconut Crust in the name of the recipe.
Will definitely make this again!
meech on 7.19.2010
This was a great dessert! I made a few changes – I don’t know if it’s just me or not, but I couldn’t find the same size condensed milk here in Canada, so I used the only size I could find which is 300 mls. I actually only used one and a half tins – because I used the other half of the tin for a different dessert. This doesn’t even come close to the 2 x 14 ozs. I didn’t adjust the amount of lime juice or cream to compensate and it still came out delicious. The crust is great too – love the coconut. All around it was just yummy. Thanks.
Mama Holli of Nobody Puts Mama In A Corner! on 7.15.2010
My friend Lisa is from Florida and she is very picky about her Key Lime pies…I am going to attempt this one for her….it looks like a winner.
5 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
bakeaholic on 7.22.2010
Sweetened Condensed milk!
Midwest Mrs. Thats too funny! Hopefully you can redeem yourself
rghawki on 7.16.2010
Is that condensed milk or sweetened condensed milk?
Sounds yummy
Midwest Mrs on 7.15.2010
My husband loves key lime pie too. When we were first dating, I made him one. I was so proud. He took one bite and had to spit it out. He said, “I’m so sorry, I can’t eat this.” I must have screwed something up, because it tasted terrible. Hopefully I can master this recipe!
newchef on 7.8.2010
Looks delicious! I have about 10 limes I need to use! This sounds perfect! Plus my husband is one of the biggest fans of key lime pie.
krinnie on 7.8.2010
Humm. Wow, coconut in the crust! Love the idea. I’ll have to try this.