15 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
tffnyjean on 5.31.2015
This was a hit I thought it was delicious, it had the perfect mix of tartness and sweet with the whip cream. I didn’t have gelatin, so I just made the whip cream without. The coconut in the crust was delicious!
Kelly on 6.15.2014
Absolutely delicious! I made this for my husband’s birthday, and it was a big hit!
Cathey on 5.10.2014
Gluten Free- I can only comment on the filling, boy I thought I was back in Key West. I made 5 individual small cups and put a Schar gluten free graham cracker in the bottom of each. I just whipped cream, confection sugar and almond, left out the gelatin. The filling is true Key West flavor. Made this last weekend and again tonight for my Mother’s Day treat tomorrow.
Eugenia on 8.9.2012
My first time making key lime pie, and it turned out amazing! I, too, recommend using all the extra whipping cream for serving, after you’ve taken a picture of how pretty it looks. The whipped cream goes really well with it.
janette995 on 5.16.2012
Delicious! I made two this past weekend and they were a big hit. The pie is fairly tart (which is good!) with a great flavor. The second pie I made, I added an extra tablespoon of sugar to the whipped cream. I was a little skeptical of the coconut in the crust but it added a sweetness without the “coconut” flavor. And I loved learning how to stabilize whipped cream – what a great trick! Will definitely make again.
9 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Jenelle Miller on 6.24.2015
I have not eaten it yet but it set up beautifully and it tasted yummy when I licked my finger…..and I used fat-free sweetened condensed milk. I know, still all the calories but I will take whatever I can get.
tffnyjean on 5.31.2015
This was so tasty. I made it for a BBQ this past weekend, it was delicious everyone loved it!! Perfect mix of tartness and sweetness with the whip cream.
Mollie on 12.11.2013
Does anyone know how long to beat the egg yolk, zest, juice AFTER you add the condensed milk? Some say to beat it on high for a long time, others say like a minute. Please help! It’s not on her pioneer woman website either… Thanks!
donssweetheart on 12.16.2010
I just made this… It was to die for! Loved the coconut in the crust too!
mamacook on 7.2.2010
Made this tonight for my family and it was wonderful! I love the coconut in the crust. Thank you for sharing!