7 Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.
wwrawson on 11.23.2012




These were a big hit with my family! Instead of dipping each piece, I just made them as a two layered bar with semisweet chocolate. Less mess, still delicious!
blackhawkwife on 10.24.2012




These were great to make. I used almond butter, it was a bit hard to mix in with the candy corn so I will use peanut butter next time. Love this one.
garlicmakesitgood on 12.26.2011




These were so fun to make! When I read how they were made I wondered how they would come out but they were wonderful. Thanks for sharing!
ComfortablyDomestic on 10.23.2011




Fabulous! I made these with SunButter instead of peanut butter, with excellent results! My peanut allergic son was thrilled to try a “Butterfinger.”




6 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Mindy on 9.11.2012
Holy COW! These were soooo easy to make and ridiculously addictive
Big hit with the fam! I’m a little nervous to be left alone in a room with them 
maryquitecontrarybakes on 10.26.2011
And at Stinsander, the only thing I can think of is that you might not have mixed the candy corn and peanut butter enough. You have to put some muscle into it so it’s all distributed and this is what gives it the texture of the butterfinger. It takes some effort at first but comes together. Either that or possibly these were left at room temperature in a humid place? I’m not sure what else it could be. Hope this helps!!
maryquitecontrarybakes on 10.26.2011
I’m so glad you all enjoyed them! I’m actually not on twitter I guess this is incentive (a kick in the butt) to join?
rcymmolly on 10.17.2011
These were such a winner! I used chocolate almond bark instead of chocolate so it would set a little quicker. My office and my family loved them! I’m going to the store to stock up on candy corn so I can make these as Christmas gifts!
stinasander on 9.30.2011
So, the flavor was great, but mine were a little chewy, instead of “crispity, crunchity peanut buttery butterfinger! What did I do wrong???