10 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
emilyborland on 6.9.2010




Gooey cheese and crusty bread, wonderfully aromatic broth and the wonderful onions…this soup was so yummy!
shep on 10.5.2010




This was delicious. We don’t have bowls that can go under the broiler, so I made the croutons and then added some cheese and put it back under the broiler before putting them into the soup. Worked like a charm.
mel15brk on 11.22.2010




This soup was wonderful. The only thing I would change is I wouldn’t add the Worcestershire Sauce, which I usually love but the soup tasted better before we added it. This was a great cold weather meal and we’ll be making it again.
girlcancook on 1.1.2011




This was just perfect! Wouldn’t change anything on this recipe! It is truly the best homemade french onion soup I have ever made or tasted. The dry white wine and baking the onions for one hour, is what gives this soup that wonderful flavour! My family LOVED it! Thanks for sharing this recipe!
tammyhershberger on 2.5.2011




Made an early Valentine’s Day dinner tonight for my hubby (because we’re home alone this weekend without kids and I have to work next weekend!) so I made this because French Onion Soup is one of his favorites, and he loved it! We both did! Very rich and delicious. I didn’t want to invest in the pricey Gruyere cheese, so I used Monterey Jack instead and it was fabulous!
Laura on 1.26.2012




I am super picky about French Onion Soup and this recipe is AMAZING!
Note: I made mine in a cast iron chicken fryer because I couldn’t find the dutch oven I was looking for.
Helen Toma on 1.3.2013




This soup is absolutely delicious. I’m not a fan of onions in general but this was to die for!
April Nolan on 1.10.2013




Loved this soup. On a cold day here in Colorado this soup hit the spot. Yum Yum Thank you for the great recipe.
You must be logged in to post a review.





3 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
Clabbergirl on 11.18.2009
I was kinda nervous after putting in the 8 cups of broth because it was a little bland-tasting. Should I put in some bouillon cubes? Should I boil the heck out of it to reduce? All that worry for nothing! The soup was beautiful and rich after 45 minutes on simmer. The only thing I changed was the bread. I decided to do 1″ cubes so that my kiddos wouldn’t struggle with the cheese lava/hot bowl combo. I can’t stand tears at dinnertime. By the way, my 7 year old thinks melting Gruyere smells like pee. How gross is that?! However, he at it all and wanted more today. Thanks for another lovely recipe!
shellsonvancouverisland on 3.16.2010
I ended up with too much butter in relation to the amount of onions I had …. so it was a bit soup after an hour of roasting so I roasted it a bit longer which resulted in the onions disintegrating ….. which was okay. I didn’t want to open a bottle of wine because I knew it would end up getting wasted so I used a cup of sherry instead …. it turned out wonderful.
I need to know how much butter is in one stick. I buy a block of butter which is 454 grams (about a pound) and is 2 cups…. am guessing a stick of butter may be one cup???
DarcyBennet on 10.13.2010
A stick of butter is 4oz, or about 114 grams.
You must be logged in to post a comment.