146 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
Ronda C. on 5.17.2010




Perfect for my husband that doesn’t like super sweet frosting. It was light and creamy and and just plain good. Reminds me of the filling in a hostess cupcake. In fact my next batch will be as filling in some chocolate cupcakes.
Ree on 5.17.2010




A big YES on this recipe. It’s hard to imagine this combination of ingredients resulting in such a fluffy (and flavorful) icing, but somehow it delivers. I think it’s the flour that really gives it the indescribably wonderful flavor.
FWIW, I think (haven’t proven, but think) you’ll get better results if the butter is softened but not overly mushy/room temp.
Yennifah on 5.17.2010




My new favorite frosting! I love the fluffiness and that it’s not super sweet like most other frostings. This is so light that I don’t feel guilty eating a spoon full…
sourkraut on 5.18.2010




Looks like I’m in the minority in preferring traditional buttercream recipes to this. I think I might have made a few mistakes along the way, including not letting the milk/flour mixture thicken enough, resulting in a slightly separated final product without much flavor. It’s probably just the German in me talking, but I don’t deal well with imprecise recipes. A little more guidance in the instructions including approximate times probably would have helped me. Based on other reviews I’ll give it another go some time in the future, but for now I’m still seeking *THE* perfect plain frosting recipe for me.
The Sugar Tree on 5.18.2010




I wasn’t quite as excited about this as other reviewers. It did have a nice flavor, but the consistency was not what I had hoped for. If you are making it and serving it immediately, then this is great. But after it sits for any length of time at all, the texture breaks down.
melissajane on 5.18.2010




I really disliked this – was surprised by how odd it tasted. I could taste the flour, and just generally thought it had a mediocre texture and not much to recommend it.
Natalie | Perry's Plate on 5.19.2010




I read most of the comments before I tried this and made sure my roux was nice and thick. It had a perfect, fluffy texture and looked beautiful. But it tasted like bland custard. I realized I had used unsalted butter, so I threw a pinch of salt in there, which improved the flavor ever so slightly, but it still wasn’t the “best frosting I ever had”. Not even close. In fact the day after it tasted like the icky supermarket buttercream. I’m willing to try it again, though. Maybe my roux was a bit too thick.
cs3andme on 5.19.2010




I’ve made this at least four times, and it was wonderful every time! It is important to let the roux thicken up enough or it would have the tendency to separate. I’m also a fan of less-sweet frosting, so this is perfect for my family.
lillieknits on 5.19.2010




I agree that the instructions were a little too vague for me. I got freaked out that it was going to separate and probably didn’t beat it long enough. If you were to edit it to be a bit more precise you’d have a 5 star recipe on your hands. I really think traditional buttercream has a very raw, unfinished taste to it and this is far superior in my opinion.
connied on 5.19.2010




This was a very nice frosting. It tasted like melted vanilla ice cream. I do prefer buttercream frosting but this is a nice change.
You must be logged in to post a review.






171 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
vashoncoe on 5.6.2012
By far the best frosting ever. I love it best on chocolate cake or cupcakes.
KL on 5.7.2012
Do I use the salted butter or unsalted butter? I made it with unsalted butter and it really tasted bland… with a touch of floury after taste. It looked good but not sure what I did wrong…
Lydia Moore on 5.19.2012
This is by far the best frosting recipe I’ve ever had. Not too sweet to overwhelm the cake.
Mandi Warren on 8.25.2012
My frosting came out with a yellowish color & it is runny. I have used country crock butter & I have also tried making it with imperial stick butter. I use skim milk. What am I doing wrong?
Briana on 9.26.2012
I’ve tried this recipe 3 times! And everytime it comes out clumpy..ugh its driving me crazyy lol
but it taste really good but how to umake it look like that??
Patti on 9.27.2012
Hate to be a pooper, but I’ve been baking for 30 years, and I’ve made a LOT of frostings. This was one of the worst I’ve ever made. It was greasy, greasy and fatty tasting, not quite sweet enough, and just odd. It ruined the cake I put it on. You could tell there was a flour roux in it. Honestly, as much as I wanted to like this, it tasted like bad Dream Whip to me. Even my boys wouldn’t eat it, and they’ll eat just about anything.
kristy on 10.1.2012
Best icing I ever had, you really need to keep beating it for a VERY long time. I will totally make this again!!!!!!!!
Suzy on 11.18.2012
Absolutely delicious! My husband , sister and sister-in-law love this frosting.!
Irene on 12.19.2012
I just want to know. the vanilla.. is this from a vanilla pouder or so? and not from actual vanilla?
Janelle on 4.15.2013
Can this frosting be piped?
You must be logged in to post a comment.