2 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
abloomingheart7 on 7.26.2010




These cookies are so yummy and cute! I had a hard time getting the frosting to work, so I added some milk and it turned out fine. I also shaped the dough into balls instead of doing a drop cookie to make it a little rounder.
I think these would be great for a baby shower or a little girl’s birthday party! Thanks for sharing!
katalyst on 8.2.2010




I was disappointed with these. A few points about the recipe: it would be nice if the amount of Whoppers was clarified. Is it two cups before or after they’re crushed? Also, 1/4 c. of butter wasn’t nearly enough for the filling–it made dry crumbs. I used extra butter and milk, as another commenter did, to get the consistency right. The cookies stuck to the baking sheets, even when following the cooling instructions to the letter. Use parchment or grease your pans.
The taste is interesting, but not good enough that I’ll make them again. Oh, and they look nothing like the cookies in the picture. The cookie part has an oatmeal cookie-appearance (because of the Whopper bits), and the jello gives the filling more of a granulated sugar look.
You must be logged in to post a review.





9 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
italiancooking on 7.20.2010
These look delicious but what is Strawberry Milkshake Whoppers?
sadlersr on 7.21.2010
http://www.amazon.com/Whoppers-Strawberry-Milkshake-Flavored-4-Ounce/dp/B000WMI6RK
You can get them at wal-mart and probably most grocery stores in the US.
hailskitchen on 7.22.2010
What a clever idea — they sound so yummy! Cute photo, too
nursechacha on 7.23.2010
I love Whoppers but had never seen the strawberry version…whoo whoo… sounds good. Agree, very cute photo!
lisakay720 on 7.27.2010
So… do you have to refrigerate them for a week in order for them to be ready, or are you suggesting they will last a week in the fridge??
goosesgirl on 7.27.2010
They will last in the fridge for about a week. Outside of the US, especially European countries, they are called macaroons (related to coconut macaroons, but not the same). The original version is a little involved – this looks way simpler
bellamaxjoy on 7.27.2010
can these be frozen?
mharris on 7.27.2010
Yes these can be frozen, for up to 1 month.
momw4kids on 7.29.2010
I made these last night but it does not look like the ones on the picture. I did not put the rest of the Jello powder on the frosting bec. it is way too sweet. My kids did not really like it they prefer the good old chocolate chips cookies! Oh, well at least I tried.
You must be logged in to post a comment.