4 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
abarnum619 on 5.19.2010




Oh, I can’t even describe how amazing these are! So good! They are like a reeses cookie, but so much better! I will make again and again!
whiskit on 5.20.2010




WOW…these are SOOOO good! Very easy, but take longer than a typical batch of cookies because of the separate mixtures and rolling required. But the extra time is worth it! Would be a lot of fun to make with kids! Thanks for this!
Christina on 6.23.2010




This is probably the recipe from here that I’ve made the most. Though I will say it’s a million times easier with my KitchenAid. I made a batch without and had a lot of trouble getting the chocolate dough to be the right consistency. I’m not sure what I did wrong.
Definitely take a lot longer than typical cookies, but I think it’s more than worth it.
ericame on 8.3.2010




I made these a few weeks ago and they were alright. The taste was very similar to a peanut butter cookie, but it was a lot more work. I had trouble getting the chocolate batter to surround the peanut butter mixture without cracking, and ended up with a bunch of left over peanut mixture. I just don’t think these were worth the extra effort.
You must be logged in to post a review.





15 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
sprucehill on 1.20.2010
Oh these look so good!
terriab on 1.20.2010
I love these cookies and they are very easy to make.
AngieN24 on 1.20.2010
Saw Ree tweet about these so I had to try them. They are very good! Definitely a ‘cookies and milk (or coffee)’ kind of cookie. Chocolately good and rich. They are like Reese’s cookies. Delish!
Reasonable Snob on 1.22.2010
I used to make these cookies on very special occasions for my roommates. My one male roommate proposed to me every time I made them! We used a less PG name, though: peanut butter chocolate orgasms. MMMMM
Christina on 1.23.2010
Just took the second sheet of them out of the oven, but I’ve already ate a few off the first sheet. So yummy. Took me a bit to get the hang of putting them together, though. Will definitely need to make another batch so I can “practice”.
amieivy on 1.29.2010
These cookies are officially my favorite cookie…. EVER! Everything about them is just perfect!! I have made them twice in the past couple weeks and plan on making them again to send to my brother!! Sooo good!
mae27 on 3.4.2010
These were completely amazing! A little tricky sometimes to get the dough around the peanut butter, but well worth the work!
lisd4 on 3.4.2010
I have made these and they are super delicious! I love it when I find “old familiars” on Tasty Kitchen, thanks for your recipe!
suzy24 on 3.17.2010
Just finished making these. They are delish!!
allysoncady on 3.29.2010
I made these over the weekend and they were awesome. My only comment on the recipe is I had a really hard time getting 30 cookies out of the recipe, and instead had 24 (I noticed the “servings” at the top of the recipe is 24, but in the recipe text itself it says to make 30 balls). I also had to bake them for much longer than 7-9 minutes, but that could also be because I’m at a high altitude.
You must be logged in to post a comment.