6 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
morethanlifeitself on 10.26.2010




Okay, y’all. I just made this exactly as the instructions said and it is….to…d-d-d-die for!!! Unbelievably creamy and smooth and chocolate-y. Thank you Church Cook. This one is added to my recipe box and will be my go-to chocolate frosting.
prairieprincess on 10.29.2010




After the picture of this gem of a recipe was featured by Ree, i knew what I had to do. Make cupcakes that night, solely in the name of frosting, I mean science.
I’ve never attempted a true buttercream frosting. I too followed the instructions to a T and the frosting turned out perfectly. The texture was amazing. The unsweetened chocolate gave it a slightly bitter, dark chocolate taste but paired with overly sweet chocolate fudge cupcakes it was perfect. I may even use this recipe minus the unsweetened chocolate for a plain buttercream because I actually even preferred the unchocolated version over the chocolate but either way it’s delish.
savesum on 11.2.2010




Yes, real buttercream frosting is wonderful and worth the effort and time versus a buttercream made with powdered sugar.
Have no fear, keep beating and as you get to the end of adding all the butter it comes together perfectly.
Either serve right away or if you refrigerate first, make sure to leave out so the frosting will have time to soften a bit.
Sometimes I add 1-2 tablespoons of heavy cream at the end, beat on high – this makes it a bit lighter in texture.
lesliepie on 6.5.2011




We made this a few months ago and I still dream about it. The instructions are easy to follow. It is AMAZING. It tastes almost caramel-y. Thanks for a fantastic recipe!
Heather @ Dandelion Daze on 8.17.2011




This buttercream was so so so good! I have never made a “real” buttercream, in fact I never realized there was buttercream without powdered sugar until I stumbled upon this recipe. I’ll never go back! Make this…you will be so glad you did.
Shelby on 8.24.2012




Yummy!! The frosting was very rich and chocolate-y; it almost tasted like ganache. When I first started adding butter I was worried about the texture, but after all the butter was incorporated it was really fluffy frosting.
You must be logged in to post a review.






6 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
Sips and Spoonfuls on 10.23.2010
this looks so delicious…and light…can’t wait to try it!
Clayvessel on 10.23.2010
REAL buttercream with eggs and butter! Looks mahvelous!
MissyDew on 10.24.2010
I found a recipe similar to this years ago in The Cake Bible only it used just the egg yolks, not the whole egg. I made it and it was wonderfully unforgettable, completely decadent and insanely yummy. I would bet that this recipe is the same. Can’t wait to start reading the reviews. I might have to give in and make it myself, too…
americangirlinquebec on 10.24.2010
Hmm, I’ve made frosting similar to this only using egg whites before, and I just want to verify that you really do mean to use the whole egg (yolks and all) in this one. If so then I look forward to trying a new twist on buttercream!
Nessy on 10.24.2010
This does sound very nice. I’m guessing that with the whole egg used, it takes on almost a custard-like consistency. I am a big fan of the meringue type frostings, so I’m certainly going to try this one!
The Church Cook (Kay Heritage) on 10.24.2010
Hello, Americangirlinquebec! Yes you use the whole egg! Thank you for your kind comments, friends!
You must be logged in to post a comment.