49 Reviews | Be the first to review!
Reviews
jessicawells on 9.22.2010
Holy moly! These are GOOD. Too bad there was some filling left over….might just have to use a spoon. Honestly, the cookies are chewy and the filling is delicious with the peanut butter and cream cheese. Easy recipe and great results, can’t ask for anything better!
Bird Sister on 9.25.2010
Yum! And easy! Doubled the batch for a block party (notice it only yields 16 cookies) – I too had some filling left over so I’ll be making one more single batch to keep at home!
missmallorylynn on 10.3.2010
perrrrfect! i guess you really can’t go wrong with chocolate and pb, but these are so easy and delish!!
ericaleigh on 10.4.2010
These were amazing! Super quick and easy to make, too. I’ll definitely be making these again soon!
Annette on 10.6.2010
These are really good. Don’t be fooled though, the cookies will not appear completely ‘done’, but they are. They seem to firm-up after they have cooled a while. If they become too hard, the filling ‘squirts’ out from between the cookie when eating. Undercook the cookies, fill, and then put in the freezer for a great frozen treat! Almost like an ice-cream sandwich.
purrfectionist on 10.8.2010
These turned out WONDERFUL. I had nothing but extravagant compliments when I made these. They had no time to go into the fridge since they were eaten up!
alysonm on 10.12.2010
These cookies were great! Very soft and easy to make, will definitely make again.
catie27 on 10.19.2010
My friend and I made these and found that the cookies got a bit too puffy – 1″ balls could benefit from being smooshed down a bit. Ours didn’t flatten, which made the “sandwich” part of things difficult. Otherwise, we loved the flavor!
pauladavis on 10.27.2010
Perfect and amazing. You know the cookies are done when they start to crack on top! Don’t take them out until you see them do that. My guests loved them and I’m going to make them all the time for potlucks!
You must be logged in to post a review.
30 Comments | Be the first to comment!
Comments
purrfectionist on 10.8.2010
This turned out WONDERFUL. I had nothing but extravagant compliments when I made these. They had no time to go into the fridge since they were eaten up!
pattyhans on 10.12.2010
Yum, yum, yum. These are wonderful – my family went nuts for them!
radioheart on 10.17.2010
Has anyone tried substituting a brownie mix for the cake mix? I may try that just to see.
landynlogan on 10.26.2010
I had family coming to town from Rome and I made three desserts from this web site. They just loved all of them. This recipe was so easy and delicious. I had some of the peanut butter mixture left over in the fridge. I let it warm up and whipped up another batch of cookies. My sister in law loved them and by the next day they were all gone. YUMMY Thanks for the great, easy recipe.
pauladavis on 10.27.2010
wow, i’m going to make these today! i love when i just need to buy one ingredient (cake mix!)
ashleyjayne on 10.31.2010
I’m not sure why I wasn’t able to write a review, but I made these today and wow! So easy, so good. Not to mention it was easy to make them photo-worthy, just like in the picture. My only suggestion is when you roll them into a ball smoosh them a tad so the cookies are flatter for the sandwiches. Another user suggested it, and I’m glad I did! The cookies are good on their own too! Overall a great recipe. So much easier than I thought!
elina79 on 12.6.2010
hello and congrats about the wonderful recipe. i am from Athens , Greece where we dont have cake mix. i dont want to use fixed stuff. i like to make my own, so what do you suggest instead? maybe , 1/2 cup of cocoa powder and some baking soda plus some nuts would do??
thank u
lmbloch on 12.6.2010
these are dangerously good! first time i have ever seen our 6 year old lab snag food off the table right in front of us. i don’t blame her, they’re irresistible!
lucyandleiaskitchen on 12.16.2010
These were awesome and so easy! I shipped some out to family for Christmas so I used a different peanut butter filling, one without cream cheese, so that it wouldn’t spoil. Thanks for the recipe!
gotchocolate on 12.25.2010
Chocolate and peanut butter. How can you go wrong with that combo!
You must be logged in to post a comment.